WONDER — The Mystery
Why does a fret raise the note?
Shortening the vibrating part of an ideal string raises its allowed frequencies if tension and mass per unit length stay fixed. A string and an air column can share a fundamental frequency yet sound different because the relative harmonic strengths and attack and decay can differ.
Model: Ideal uniform string or cylindrical air column. Name the quantity when describing a node: air displacement and pressure nodes are opposite. Real pipes have end corrections, losses and radiation; real strings can have stiffness and inharmonicity.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictFor an ideal fixed-end string, halve its vibrating length while keeping tension and mass per unit length fixed. Its fundamental frequency:
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
The fundamental wavelength is 2L and f₁ = c/(2L). At unchanged wave speed, halving L doubles the fundamental frequency. Amplitude is a separate property.
▶ PLAY — Moving String and Longitudinal Air Modes
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Run presets 1, 2 and 3. Change mode index only at fixed length; then length only at fixed mode and boundaries. Compare the extra closed-pipe and string setups. Use Pause and Step to see air particles move along the tube while the nodes stay fixed.
Established ideal standing modes: displacement = A S(x) cos(2πft). Fixed string: S = sin(nπx/L); open–open air column: S = cos(nπx/L); closed-left/open-right column: S = sin(nπx/2L), with odd n. Mode index j maps to n = j for string/open pipes, n = 2j − 1 for closed–open pipes. Sound speed is 343 m/s and air density 1.2 kg/m³; string wave speed is 160 m/s at fixed tension and mass per length. In air, pressure variation = −ρc² × displacement gradient (extension). Both curves and actual longitudinal markers follow this same solution. A 16 ms physical window plays in 6 real seconds; Step advances .100 ms. Air motion uses 3000000 pixels/m horizontally; string motion and displacement plots 7000000 pixels/m; pressure uses 3 pixels/Pa. The tube length fills 360 pixels, so that spatial scale changes with L. No amplitude rescaling between modes, damping, mode-formation transient, end correction or audio is included.
Status: Ready
Playback: 6 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Boundaries Select the Modes
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all four rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Fixed-end strings
Click to flip
Fixed-end strings
A displacement node is permanently at rest; an antinode has maximum oscillation amplitude. For a string fixed at both ends, λₙ = 2L/n and fₙ = nc/(2L), n = 1, 2, 3, … . Harmonic n has n antinodes and n + 1 displacement nodes including its ends. Adjacent nodes are λ/2 apart.
Rule 2
Open–open air columns
Click to flip
Open–open air columns
Ideal openings are displacement antinodes and pressure nodes. Allowed frequencies are fₙ = nc/(2L), for all positive integer n. For displacement there are n nodes and n + 1 antinodes including openings. Pressure and displacement nodes exchange positions. Air moves along the tube; a vertical quantity plot does not show transverse air motion.
Rule 3
Closed–open air columns
Click to flip
Closed–open air columns
At a rigid closed end, displacement is a node and pressure an antinode; the ideal opening has the opposite conditions. λₙ = 4L/n and fₙ = nc/(4L) for odd n = 1, 3, 5, … . Mode index j has harmonic n = 2j − 1: the first overtone is the third harmonic. A displacement node to the adjacent antinode is λ/4.
Rule 4
Pitch and timbre
Click to flip
Pitch and timbre
At fixed string tension T and mass per length μ, c = √(T/μ) and f₁ ∝ 1/L. Changing one variable requires the others to be specified. Doubling frequency gives an octave. Allowed harmonics do not require equal or nonzero measured strength; timbre also involves relative amplitudes and the time envelope. Strings and real bores can depart from ideal harmonic ratios.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: The second allowed mode of an ideal closed–open pipe is its second harmonic.
Correct — the claim is false.
Only odd harmonic numbers fit. The second allowed mode is n = 3, also called the first overtone; the second harmonic is absent in this ideal model.
Myth 2: A pressure node in a sound standing wave is also an air-displacement node.
Correct — the claim is false.
The spatial nodes are opposite: a pressure node is a displacement antinode and a pressure antinode is a displacement node. At a rigid end, air cannot move normally to the wall but pressure can vary.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Read Boundaries Before Calculating
DOK 2 — ApplyUse node positions and harmonic labels, then complete two calculations under ideal conditions.
Instructor Q1 — Pressure boundary
At the rigid closed end of an ideal closed–open pipe, which pair is correct?
Instructor Q2 — Second mode
The second allowed axial mode in a closed–open pipe has harmonic number:
Instructor Q3 — String harmonic
An ideal fixed-end string has fundamental 180 Hz. Find its fourth harmonic frequency.
Instructor Q4 — Open column
An ideal open–open column is .500 m long; c = 340 m/s. Find its fundamental frequency.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
State the boundary conditions and the plotted quantity. Harmonic number, mode index and overtone number are different labels; the lowest observed peak need not be the fundamental.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Harmonic and Instrument Audits
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Fixed String Mode
An ideal string fixed at both ends has fundamental frequency 145.5 Hz. Find the frequency of harmonic n = 3 and the number of its internal displacement nodes, excluding the two endpoints.
Step-by-Step Solution
f₃ = 3 × 145.5 = 436.5 Hz. There are n + 1 = 4 total nodes, of which 2 are internal.
Challenge 2: A Closed–Open Column
An ideal cylindrical air column is closed at one end and open at the other. Its length is .425 m and sound speed is 340 m/s. Find its fundamental frequency, first-overtone frequency, and the wavelength of that first overtone.
Step-by-Step Solution
Fundamental f₁ = 340/(4 × .425) = 200 Hz. The first overtone has n = 3, so its frequency is 600 Hz and wavelength = 340/600 = .566667 m.
Challenge 3: Identify an Unknown Tube
For one ideal cylindrical tube, recorded resonances are 315, 525 and 735 Hz. Assume these are consecutive allowed axial modes of either an open–open or a closed–open tube. Lower frequencies were outside the recorded range. Sound speed is 350 m/s; ignore end correction. Infer the boundary type, true fundamental, length, next allowed frequency above 735 Hz, and harmonic number of the 735 Hz mode. A report calls 315 Hz the fundamental, calls 735 Hz the third harmonic because it is the third recorded peak, says both boundary types fit, and places a pressure node at a rigid closed end. Correct all four claims and justify how the spacing and ratios distinguish the two models. Explain what further measurement could test your inference.
Explanation checks are indicative. Compare your reasoning with the worked solution or your teacher.
Step-by-Step Solution
Spacing is 210 Hz. For an open–open tube consecutive modes would have f₁ = 210 Hz, but 315/210 = 1.5 is not an integer, so that model fails the assumptions. A closed–open tube has spacing 2f₁, giving f₁ = 105 Hz and labels 3, 5, 7. Length = 350/(4 × 105) = .833333 m. Next n = 9 gives 945 Hz. The first recorded peak need not be fundamental; the third recorded peak is n = 7, not n = 3. A rigid end is a pressure antinode. Search below the measured band for a 105 Hz mode, or measure endpoint motion/pressure. Real losses, missing detections and end correction could require revisiting the ideal inference.
☷ CHALLENGE — Classify the Boundary Evidence
DOK 2 — ApplyClassify the Boundary Evidence
Select each statement and place it in its matching category. Judge the physical conditions.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
State the boundary conditions and the plotted quantity. Harmonic number, mode index and overtone number are different labels; the lowest observed peak need not be the fundamental.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why a fret raises pitch and how string and air-column boundaries select harmonics. Distinguish air-displacement and pressure nodes and include the meaning of an overtone.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 13.8 — Music Math: Harmonics and Standing Waves
Reach the Peak of Understanding
1. Fixed-end strings
A displacement node is permanently at rest; an antinode has maximum oscillation amplitude. For a string fixed at both ends, λₙ = 2L/n and fₙ = nc/(2L), n = 1, 2, 3, … . Harmonic n has n antinodes and n + 1 displacement nodes including its ends. Adjacent nodes are λ/2 apart.
2. Open–open air columns
Ideal openings are displacement antinodes and pressure nodes. Allowed frequencies are fₙ = nc/(2L), for all positive integer n. For displacement there are n nodes and n + 1 antinodes including openings. Pressure and displacement nodes exchange positions. Air moves along the tube; a vertical quantity plot does not show transverse air motion.
3. Closed–open air columns
At a rigid closed end, displacement is a node and pressure an antinode; the ideal opening has the opposite conditions. λₙ = 4L/n and fₙ = nc/(4L) for odd n = 1, 3, 5, … . Mode index j has harmonic n = 2j − 1: the first overtone is the third harmonic. A displacement node to the adjacent antinode is λ/4.
4. Pitch and timbre
At fixed string tension T and mass per length μ, c = √(T/μ) and f₁ ∝ 1/L. Changing one variable requires the others to be specified. Doubling frequency gives an octave. Allowed harmonics do not require equal or nonzero measured strength; timbre also involves relative amplitudes and the time envelope. Strings and real bores can depart from ideal harmonic ratios.
Worked independent practice
C1: 436.5 Hz and 2 internal nodes. C2: 200 Hz, 600 Hz and .566667 m. C3: closed–open, 105 Hz, .833333 m, 945 Hz and harmonic 7; justify the odd sequence and test below the recorded band.
Live investigation and access
Established ideal standing modes: displacement = A S(x) cos(2πft). Fixed string: S = sin(nπx/L); open–open air column: S = cos(nπx/L); closed-left/open-right column: S = sin(nπx/2L), with odd n. Mode index j maps to n = j for string/open pipes, n = 2j − 1 for closed–open pipes. Sound speed is 343 m/s and air density 1.2 kg/m³; string wave speed is 160 m/s at fixed tension and mass per length. In air, pressure variation = −ρc² × displacement gradient (extension). Both curves and actual longitudinal markers follow this same solution. A 16 ms physical window plays in 6 real seconds; Step advances .100 ms. Air motion uses 3000000 pixels/m horizontally; string motion and displacement plots 7000000 pixels/m; pressure uses 3 pixels/Pa. The tube length fills 360 pixels, so that spatial scale changes with L. No amplitude rescaling between modes, damping, mode-formation transient, end correction or audio is included.
Run, Pause, Step and Reset work offline. Complete three matched measurements. Loading a preset is not completing a trial. Saved progress resumes paused. Reduced-motion Run gives a final snapshot; Step allows deliberate inspection. Hints and solutions require a genuine unsuccessful numerical attempt and never complete a task. Explanation rubrics are indicative; compare your physics with the solution or a teacher. Teaching submission checks effort rather than certifying scientific accuracy.
Course scope
Cambridge AS 9702 8.1 covers stationary waves, nodes, antinodes and determining wavelengths for strings and air columns. AP Physics 2 14.6 covers standing waves, harmonics and open/closed pipes. Explicit pressure-gradient calculations, sparse-spectrum diagnosis and detailed real-instrument timbre are extension or enrichment.
Sources: Cambridge International 9702 syllabus ; College Board AP Physics 2 CED. Detailed extension models are labelled in the mission.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I name displacement or pressure when discussing nodes.
- I distinguish harmonic number, mode index and overtone.
- I use the correct wavelength and boundary conditions.
- I keep string conditions fixed when changing length.
- I test the lowest observed peak before calling it fundamental.
— Crest ☆ “Reach the Peak of Understanding”
Mission 13.8 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Music Math: Harmonics and Standing Waves Investigator
State the boundary conditions and the plotted quantity. Harmonic number, mode index and overtone number are different labels; the lowest observed peak need not be the fundamental.