WONDER — The Mystery
A Fixed Source Tone Can Reach You at a Different Rate
An approaching siren is heard at a higher pitch than the same siren receding. The source can keep the same oscillation rate while motion changes the spacing of its emitted wavefronts. Sound speed is set by the medium, rather than by adding the source speed.
Model: Classical sound in uniform still air, with steady source and observer velocities along their joining line. Velocities are measured relative to the air. The live source remains subsonic and never passes the observer. Wavefront geometry is shown; amplitudes, hearing, wind gradients, reflections and nonlinear shocks are outside this model.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA steady source moves toward a stationary observer in still air. Compared with the emitted frequency, the observed frequency is:
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
Approaching source motion shortens wavefront spacing ahead. At the unchanged medium sound speed, a stationary observer receives more crests per second; the source emission frequency stays fixed in this model.
▶ PLAY — Live Emission Centres and Crest Arrivals
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure the stationary baseline, change only source velocity, then change only source frequency from the baseline. Compare moving-observer and comoving setups as extensions.
Uniform still air has c = 343 m/s. A source starts at x = 0 and an observer at x = 60 m. Positive velocities point right. A crest is emitted every 1/f_s seconds, including the first at t = 0. Its centre stays at the emission position and its radius grows at c. The observer remains ahead throughout each .300 s trial, played over six real seconds. Positions and radii share 1.5 pixels/m; the view is cropped without a wall. Arrows indicate direction schematically. Readouts use f_obs = f_s(c − u_o)/(c − u_s), with signed air-frame velocities. The moving-observer equation is extension; AP Doppler calculations are extension. No audio or shock wave is modeled.
Status: Ready
Playback: 6 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Spacing, Encounter Rate and the Air Frame
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Moving source, stationary observer
Click to flip
Moving source, stationary observer
For straight-line subsonic motion, f_obs = f_s c/(c − v_s) for approach and f_s c/(c + v_s) for recession, where v_s is a positive speed magnitude. Ahead spacing is (c − v_s)/f_s; behind it is (c + v_s)/f_s. The source period and medium sound speed stay fixed. Equal approach/recession speeds do not give equal-magnitude frequency shifts.
Rule 2
Moving observer: extension
Click to flip
Moving observer: extension
For right-going sound with the observer ahead, f_obs = f_s(c − u_o)/(c − u_s), using signed velocities relative to still air. Observer motion changes the encounter rate with an existing pattern; source motion changes its spacing. Equal closing speeds alone do not specify the same shift. Equal source and observer velocities give f_obs = f_s.
Rule 3
Historical emission centres
Click to flip
Historical emission centres
Each circle remains centred where it was emitted. Its radius is c times its age; it does not follow the current source. A detector first waits for sound to reach it, then receives successive crests at the observed period. First-arrival delay is not the period. The circles represent wavefronts, not paths of air particles.
Rule 4
Sonic limits and applications
Click to flip
Sonic limits and applications
The ordinary approach formula is not a physical infinite-pitch prediction at v_s = c. Sonic/supersonic shocks require a different model. A sonic boom is a rapid pressure change as a shock passes, not a sustained infinitely high tone. Mach number is speed/c; ideal supersonic cone geometry has sinμ = 1/M (extension). Ultrasound flow measurements involve reflected waves; light and radar use electromagnetic Doppler relationships.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “The approaching source makes each wave travel at c + v_s in still air.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Fronts travel at c in the air frame. Source motion changes their emission centres and spacing.
Myth 2: “At Mach 1, the ordinary Doppler formula proves a real infinitely high tone.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The steady subsonic formula reaches its validity limit. Actual shocks and sonic booms require a different physical description.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Identify the Doppler Mechanism
DOK 2 — ApplySpecify what moves relative to the air and whether it approaches or recedes.
Instructor Q1 — Approach
A source approaches a stationary listener while keeping its tone fixed. The listener hears:
Instructor Q2 — Recession
The source moves away from a stationary listener. Which description fits?
Instructor Q3 — Approaching Tone
In still air c = 340 m/s. A 400 Hz source approaches a stationary observer at 34 m/s. Find observed frequency.
Instructor Q4 — Mach Number
A source speed is 680 m/s where c = 340 m/s. Find its Mach number (dimensionless).
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Use the medium frame: moving the source changes spacing, while moving the observer changes how fast fronts are encountered.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Doppler and Frame Audits
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Fresh Approaching Source
A source emitting 750 Hz approaches a stationary observer directly at 45.0 m/s in still air. Sound speed is 345 m/s. Find the observed frequency.
Step-by-Step Solution
f_obs = 750 × 345/(345 − 45.0) = 862.5 Hz.
Challenge 2: Infer Motion from a Tone
A source emits 640 Hz and approaches a stationary observer directly in still air with c = 338 m/s. The observer measures 832 Hz. Find the source speed and the crest spacing ahead of the source.
Step-by-Step Solution
832 = 640 × 338/(338 − v_s), so v_s = 338(1 − 640/832) = 78.0 m/s. Ahead spacing = 338/832 = .40625 m, also (338 − 78)/640.
Challenge 3: Same Closing Speed, Different Shift
Two head-on tests use f_s = 520 Hz and still-air c = 340 m/s. In A, the source approaches a stationary observer at 34 m/s. In B, the source is stationary and the observer approaches it at 34 m/s. Calculate both observed frequencies and explain why equal closing speed does not guarantee equal Doppler shifts for sound. A report says wavefronts travel at c plus source speed, old circles recentre on the current source, and the source period changes because it moves. Correct all three claims. The moving-observer calculation is extension.
Explanation checks are indicative. Compare your reasoning with the worked solution or your teacher.
Step-by-Step Solution
A: 520 × 340/(340 − 34) = 577.78 Hz. B: 520 × (340 + 34)/340 = 572 Hz. Source motion changes spacing; observer motion changes encounter rate with the existing spacing. Sound has a medium frame, so closing speed alone is insufficient. Fronts move at c in the still air, circles retain their emission centres, and the prescribed source period remains 1/520 s.
☷ CHALLENGE — Classify the Motion and Model
DOK 2 — ApplyClassify the Motion and Model
Select each statement and place it in its matching category. Judge the physical conditions.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Use the medium frame: moving the source changes spacing, while moving the observer changes how fast fronts are encountered.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain an approaching and receding siren using wavefront spacing, unchanged medium sound speed, and the distinction between source motion and observer motion.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 13.5 — Moving Sound: Doppler Effect
Reach the Peak of Understanding
1. Moving source, stationary observer
For straight-line subsonic motion, f_obs = f_s c/(c − v_s) for approach and f_s c/(c + v_s) for recession, where v_s is a positive speed magnitude. Ahead spacing is (c − v_s)/f_s; behind it is (c + v_s)/f_s. The source period and medium sound speed stay fixed. Equal approach/recession speeds do not give equal-magnitude frequency shifts.
2. Moving observer: extension
For right-going sound with the observer ahead, f_obs = f_s(c − u_o)/(c − u_s), using signed velocities relative to still air. Observer motion changes the encounter rate with an existing pattern; source motion changes its spacing. Equal closing speeds alone do not specify the same shift. Equal source and observer velocities give f_obs = f_s.
3. Historical emission centres
Each circle remains centred where it was emitted. Its radius is c times its age; it does not follow the current source. A detector first waits for sound to reach it, then receives successive crests at the observed period. First-arrival delay is not the period. The circles represent wavefronts, not paths of air particles.
4. Sonic limits and applications
The ordinary approach formula is not a physical infinite-pitch prediction at v_s = c. Sonic/supersonic shocks require a different model. A sonic boom is a rapid pressure change as a shock passes, not a sustained infinitely high tone. Mach number is speed/c; ideal supersonic cone geometry has sinμ = 1/M (extension). Ultrasound flow measurements involve reflected waves; light and radar use electromagnetic Doppler relationships.
Worked independent practice
C1: 862.5 Hz. C2: 78.0 m/s and .40625 m. C3: A 577.78 Hz, B 572 Hz; explain the medium frame, spacing versus encounter rate, and three corrected report claims.
Live investigation and access
Uniform still air has c = 343 m/s. A source starts at x = 0 and an observer at x = 60 m. Positive velocities point right. A crest is emitted every 1/f_s seconds, including the first at t = 0. Its centre stays at the emission position and its radius grows at c. The observer remains ahead throughout each .300 s trial, played over six real seconds. Positions and radii share 1.5 pixels/m; the view is cropped without a wall. Arrows indicate direction schematically. Readouts use f_obs = f_s(c − u_o)/(c − u_s), with signed air-frame velocities. The moving-observer equation is extension; AP Doppler calculations are extension. No audio or shock wave is modeled.
Run, Pause, Step and Reset work offline. Complete three matched measurements. Loading a preset is not completing a trial. Saved progress resumes paused. Reduced-motion Run gives a final snapshot; Step allows deliberate inspection. Hints and solutions require a genuine unsuccessful numerical attempt and never complete a task. Explanation rubrics are indicative; compare your physics with the solution or a teacher. Teaching submission checks effort rather than certifying scientific accuracy.
Course scope
Cambridge AS 9702 7.3 includes moving-source, stationary-observer Doppler calculations. AP Physics 2 14.5 requires qualitative Doppler reasoning; these numerical calculations are extension for AP. Moving-observer formulas and Mach-cone geometry are enrichment.
Sources: Cambridge International 9702 syllabus ; College Board AP Physics 2 CED. Detailed extension models are labelled in the mission.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I use velocities relative to the medium.
- I distinguish emitted and observed frequency.
- I keep emission centres fixed for old fronts.
- I separate first-arrival delay from period.
- I recognise the subsonic model limit.
— Crest ☆ “Reach the Peak of Understanding”
Mission 13.5 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Moving Sound: Doppler Effect Investigator
Use the medium frame: moving the source changes spacing, while moving the observer changes how fast fronts are encountered.