WONDER — The Mystery
Why a Copper Tube Slows a Falling Magnet
Copper is weakly diamagnetic rather than ferromagnetic, yet a moving magnet can induce currents in it. In a continuous conducting tube those currents exert a braking force and dissipate energy. The magnet is slowed, not levitated indefinitely: at terminal descent gravitational energy becomes heat.
Model: For a fixed oriented loop, ε = −dλ/dt, where λ is flux linkage. In a resistive closed circuit with negligible inductance, I = ε/R. Its magnetic effect opposes the change in externally imposed flux. Opposition to flux change is the general rule; opposition to motion describes particular passive motion-driven arrangements.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictThe north pole of an axial magnet approaches a closed resistive coil. Neglect self-inductance. Which near-face polarity is induced?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
For this simple axial approach the near face is north. Viewed from the magnet, the conventional current is counterclockwise. The result assumes a closed circuit and negligible inductive memory.
▶ PLAY — A Moving Dipole and Its Induced Coil Current
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare approach and recession at the same pole, then reverse the pole at one speed. Try zero speed and an open circuit. Watch physical magnet translation, current sense and magnetic braking.
Extension: a point dipole of signed moment ±0.50 A m² moves along the axis of a 50-turn circular coil of radius 0.025 m. The coil normal is +x, pointing right. Initially the dipole is x = −0.12 m; its prescribed velocity v is positive toward the coil. Distance d = 0.12−vt remains positive. External flux per turn is Φ = μ0 m a²/[2(a²+d²)^(3/2)], and ε = −50 dΦ/dt. The closed coil has R = 10 Ω and negligible self-inductance and back-reaction on the prescribed dipole field, so I = ε/R. Magnetic force on the dipole is I times the position gradient of external linkage; an external actuator maintains the motion. Open circuit gives zero current but can retain e.m.f. A 0.50 s physical interval plays over 6 real seconds. Side-view dimensions are schematic. A separate current inset is viewed from the magnet, looking right: positive current is clockwise in that view.
Status: Ready
Playback: 6 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Oppose the Change, Track the Sign
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Signed flux change
Click to flip
Signed flux change
Choose an area normal, then distinguish signed flux from its magnitude. A negative flux becoming more negative has a negative derivative, even though its magnitude increases. ε = −dλ/dt uses that signed derivative.
Rule 2
Current and viewpoint
Click to flip
Current and viewpoint
First infer the required induced field, then use a coil grip rule. Counterclockwise current viewed face-on makes that face north; clockwise makes it south. State the viewpoint. An open circuit can have induced e.m.f. without a sustained conduction current.
Rule 3
Axial magnet example
Click to flip
Axial magnet example
With negligible inductance in a passive closed coil, an approaching pole produces a same-pole near face and repulsion; a receding pole produces the opposite near face and attraction. This table is not a universal substitute for signed flux analysis.
Rule 4
Energy accounting
Click to flip
Energy accounting
In the prescribed-motion resistive model, force opposes velocity and external mechanical power equals I²R. With appreciable inductance, magnetic energy storage and current history also matter. Lenz’s sign is consistent with conservation of energy.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “The induced field always points opposite to the original field.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. For decreasing flux it can point in the same direction to oppose the decrease.
Myth 2: “An open coil must have no induced e.m.f. when the magnet moves.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Changing linkage can induce e.m.f.; a closed conducting path is required for the modeled sustained current and braking force.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Signed Flux and Coil Direction
DOK 2 — ApplyState the viewing direction and distinguish flux from flux linkage.
Instructor Q1 — South Approaches
A south pole approaches a closed resistive coil with negligible inductance. Its near face becomes:
Instructor Q2 — North Recedes
Viewed from a receding north pole, the induced conventional current is:
Instructor Q3 — Positive Flux Falls
For a 10-turn coil, signed flux per turn falls uniformly from +0.020 to +0.010 Wb over 0.50 s. Find signed e.m.f.
Instructor Q4 — Resistive Current
A coil circuit of resistance 8.0 Ω has signed induced e.m.f. −0.40 V and negligible inductance. Find signed current.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
The induced effect opposes the flux change, not necessarily the existing flux; an open circuit is not a closed conducting brake.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Induction Direction Audits
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Signed Induced E.m.f.
A 20-turn fixed coil has signed flux per turn increasing uniformly from +0.0060 to +0.0140 Wb in 0.040 s. Find signed induced e.m.f. relative to the positive circulation paired with the stated area normal.
Step-by-Step Solution
ΔΦ = +0.0080 Wb, so ε = −20×0.0080/0.040 = −4.0 V.
Challenge 2: Negative Flux Becomes More Negative
A 30-turn fixed coil has signed per-turn external flux changing uniformly from −0.0020 to −0.0060 Wb in 0.20 s. Its closed circuit resistance is 5.0 Ω and self-inductance is negligible. Find signed e.m.f. and signed current. Positive current is counterclockwise viewed from the tip of the chosen normal.
Step-by-Step Solution
ΔΦ = −0.0040 Wb; ε = −30(−0.0040)/0.20 = +0.60 V. I = +0.60/5.0 = +0.120 A, counterclockwise from the normal tip.
Challenge 3: Audit an Eddy-Current Brake
An ideal passive resistive magnetic brake has negligible inductive energy storage. At one instant its induced e.m.f. magnitude is 0.60 V, effective loop resistance 3.0 Ω and conductor speed 0.10 m/s. Find heating power and braking-force magnitude. A report says the induced field always opposes the existing field, the magnet provides free heating energy, and opening every conducting loop leaves the same braking force. Correct all three claims and describe what happens when motion ceases after all transient currents have decayed.
Explanation checks are indicative. Compare your reasoning with the worked solution or your teacher.
Step-by-Step Solution
I = 0.60/3.0 = 0.20 A; P = I²R = 0.120 W; F = P/v = 1.20 N opposite motion. Lenz’s law opposes flux change, so an induced field can support a decreasing original field. Mechanical work supplies heat; a passive magnet is not continuous free energy. Opening all loops prevents modeled sustained currents and braking. After motion and transients cease there is no induction braking in this model.
☷ CHALLENGE — A Direction-Analysis Method
DOK 2 — ApplyA Direction-Analysis Method
Order the six steps of a consistent direction analysis.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
The induced effect opposes the flux change, not necessarily the existing flux; an open circuit is not a closed conducting brake.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain signed flux change, clockwise conventions, open versus closed circuits, axial magnet examples and energy transfer in a passive magnetic brake.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 11.13 — Lenz’s Law
Reach the Peak of Understanding
1. Signed flux change
Choose an area normal, then distinguish signed flux from its magnitude. A negative flux becoming more negative has a negative derivative, even though its magnitude increases. ε = −dλ/dt uses that signed derivative.
2. Current and viewpoint
First infer the required induced field, then use a coil grip rule. Counterclockwise current viewed face-on makes that face north; clockwise makes it south. State the viewpoint. An open circuit can have induced e.m.f. without a sustained conduction current.
3. Axial magnet example
With negligible inductance in a passive closed coil, an approaching pole produces a same-pole near face and repulsion; a receding pole produces the opposite near face and attraction. This table is not a universal substitute for signed flux analysis.
4. Energy accounting
In the prescribed-motion resistive model, force opposes velocity and external mechanical power equals I²R. With appreciable inductance, magnetic energy storage and current history also matter. Lenz’s sign is consistent with conservation of energy.
5. Copper tube and braking limits
A moving magnet induces eddy currents in continuous conducting paths. Gravitational potential energy becomes heat during slow terminal descent. Passive eddy-current braking diminishes as motion-induced current tends to zero; it does not alone hold a stationary vehicle. Copper has a weak diamagnetic response, not ferromagnetic attraction.
6. Inductive memory
In an RL circuit, L dI/dt + RI = εexternal. Current need not have the same instantaneous sign as external e.m.f. after a rapid change. Approach/repel tables assume the stated negligible-inductance response.
Worked independent practice
C1: −4.0 V. C2: +0.60 V and +0.120 A. C3: 0.120 W and 1.20 N; correct change-versus-field, mechanical energy, circuit opening and stationary braking claims.
Live investigation and access
Extension: a point dipole of signed moment ±0.50 A m² moves along the axis of a 50-turn circular coil of radius 0.025 m. The coil normal is +x, pointing right. Initially the dipole is x = −0.12 m; its prescribed velocity v is positive toward the coil. Distance d = 0.12−vt remains positive. External flux per turn is Φ = μ0 m a²/[2(a²+d²)^(3/2)], and ε = −50 dΦ/dt. The closed coil has R = 10 Ω and negligible self-inductance and back-reaction on the prescribed dipole field, so I = ε/R. Magnetic force on the dipole is I times the position gradient of external linkage; an external actuator maintains the motion. Open circuit gives zero current but can retain e.m.f. A 0.50 s physical interval plays over 6 real seconds. Side-view dimensions are schematic. A separate current inset is viewed from the magnet, looking right: positive current is clockwise in that view.
Run, Pause, Step and Reset work offline. Complete three matched measurements. Loading a preset is not completing a trial. Saved progress resumes paused. Reduced-motion Run gives a final snapshot; Step allows deliberate inspection. Hints and solutions require a genuine unsuccessful numerical attempt and never complete a task. Explanation rubrics are indicative; compare your physics with the solution or a teacher. Teaching submission checks effort rather than certifying scientific accuracy.
Course scope
Lenz’s law and Faraday’s law are required in A Level 9702 20.5 and AP Physics 2 12.4. The exact point-dipole flux and mechanical force model are labelled extensions.
Sources: Cambridge International 9702 syllabus ; College Board AP Physics 2 CED. Detailed extension models are labelled in the mission.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I choose a flux normal.
- I oppose the flux change.
- I state the current viewpoint.
- I distinguish e.m.f. from current.
- I track mechanical work and heat.
— Crest ☆ “Reach the Peak of Understanding”
Mission 11.13 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Lenz’s Law Investigator
The induced effect opposes the flux change, not necessarily the existing flux; an open circuit is not a closed conducting brake.