WONDER — The Mystery
Two Forces, Two Responses
Like point charges repel and opposite point charges attract. Each object feels an equal-magnitude, opposite-direction electric force from the other. Their accelerations can differ because their masses differ. A charged object can also attract a nearby neutral polarizable body; attraction alone does not identify its net charge.
Model: Use stationary or slowly moving point charges in the electrostatic approximation. Coulomb forces form an equal-and-opposite pair. The usual repulsion test assumes isolated, simply charged classroom objects, without external fields or complicated charge patterns. Neutral objects contain charged particles and may polarize.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA known negative object attracts B and repels C in the usual isolated classroom charge-test model. Which inference is justified?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
Repulsion of C indicates the same negative sign under the stated assumptions. B can be positive or neutral and polarizable; attraction is not enough to decide.
▶ PLAY — Live Equal-Force, Unequal-Acceleration Lab
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two runs changing only A’s charge, then a third changing only B’s mass. Watch the two particles move and compare signed electric forces and accelerations. You can also set B’s net charge to zero to inspect the limits of the point-charge model.
Two particles start at rest 0.24 m apart on a horizontal frictionless line. A has mass 1 g; B has the selected mass. Charges are in nC. Coulomb force is recomputed as the separation changes, with k = 9.00 × 10⁹ N m²/C². A small-step velocity-Verlet calculation advances 12 model seconds. At separation 0.08 m an ideal catch stops both particles; later readouts still report their electric interaction and electric-force contribution to acceleration, with the catch supplying balancing force. A zero-charge point particle has no internal polarization in this model; it must not stand in for actual neutral paper or a conductor.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Interactions and What They Prove
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Signs determine direction
Click to flip
Signs determine direction
Like point charges repel; opposite point charges attract. Each force acts along the line joining them. Right is the positive direction in the lab.
Rule 2
Neutral can polarize
Click to flip
Neutral can polarize
A nearby charged object can redistribute mobile charge or slightly displace bound charge in a neutral body. In a nonuniform field the nearer opposite charge can yield net attraction without changing the body’s total charge.
Rule 3
Equal forces, different acceleration
Click to flip
Equal forces, different acceleration
For a two-body electrostatic interaction, FA = −FB, regardless of unequal charge magnitudes or masses. Electric acceleration contribution is F/m, so the lighter body has the larger magnitude.
Rule 4
Respect the test assumptions
Click to flip
Respect the test assumptions
Repulsion is conclusive for the usual isolated, simply charged objects. Attraction alone permits opposite net charges or a charged and neutral polarizable pair. No visible motion is not proof of neutrality: support, weak force or other effects may hide it.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Attraction proves that both objects have opposite net charges.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A charged object can attract a neutral polarizable object in a nonuniform field.
Myth 2: “The heavier object exerts a larger mutual electric force.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The pair forces are equal and opposite; unequal masses give unequal electric accelerations.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Signs, Evidence and Acceleration
DOK 2 — ApplyAssume the usual isolated classroom charge-test model, and distinguish electric forces from any support forces.
Instructor Q1 — Repulsion Test
A positive reference object repels X. What can be inferred in the stated model?
Instructor Q2 — Attraction Test
A negative reference object attracts Y without touching it. Which statement is justified?
Instructor Q3 — One Force Pair
A exerts an electric force +0.024 N on B. Find the signed electric force that B exerts on A; right is positive.
Instructor Q4 — Acceleration Magnitudes
Two bodies exert mutual electric forces of magnitude 0.036 N. Body B has mass 0.012 kg. Find its electric acceleration magnitude.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
A mutual force pair has equal magnitudes; observed attraction does not uniquely determine both net charges.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Force and Logic Audits
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Signed Reaction Force
A exerts an electric force of −0.018 N on B. Right is positive. Determine the signed electric force exerted by B on A.
Step-by-Step Solution
The pair obeys FA = −FB, so FA = +0.018 N.
Challenge 2: Unequal Masses
Two isolated particles interact electrically. A has mass 0.006 kg and B has mass 0.018 kg. The electric force on A is +0.054 N, with right positive. Find the signed electric force on B and each particle’s signed electric acceleration.
Step-by-Step Solution
FB = −0.054 N. aA = 0.054/0.006 = +9 m/s²; aB = −0.054/0.018 = −3 m/s². Equal force magnitudes do not imply equal acceleration magnitudes.
Challenge 3: Audit a Charge-Test Report
In the usual isolated classroom test, a known negative body attracts a neutral polarizable body B without contact. The electric force on B is −0.028 N. A positive body C repels another simply charged body D. A report says attraction proves B is positively charged, C’s repulsion proves D is neutral, and B pushes back more weakly because it has less mass. Find the signed electric force B exerts on the negative body, using right as positive. Explain all three report errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
The electric force on the negative body is +0.028 N. B remains net neutral: polarization can explain attraction. C’s repulsion identifies D as positive in the stated simple-object model. B’s reaction force is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, regardless of mass.
☷ CHALLENGE — Classify the Stated Interaction
DOK 2 — ApplyClassify the Stated Interaction
Use the stated simple-object models; the last category refers to the electric monopole force only.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
Zero force for a zero-charge point particle must not be generalized to every real neutral object.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain attraction, repulsion and the limits of a charge test. Include neutral polarization, the assumptions behind the repulsion inference, equal opposite mutual forces and why unequal masses can accelerate differently.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 9.2 — Electric Force & Charge Interactions
Infer charge cautiously and distinguish equal forces from equal accelerations.
1. Charge interactions
Like point charges repel and opposite point charges attract. Coulomb’s law gives the magnitude F = k|qAqB|/r² in vacuum or approximately air. Use the line joining the charges for direction. k = 9.00 × 10⁹ N m²/C² is the rounded lesson constant.
2. A neutral body can attract
Neutral means equal total positive and negative charge, not an absence of charged particles. A nearby source can separate mobile charges or displace bound charges slightly. In a nonuniform field, attraction on the nearer opposite charge can exceed repulsion on the farther like charge. The body can remain net neutral throughout. Do not assign an arbitrary Coulomb qAqB/r² force to a neutral body with qB = 0 and then claim it models polarization.
3. The detective’s assumptions
For isolated, simply charged classroom objects without external fields or complex charge patches, repulsion indicates both are charged with the same sign. Attraction permits opposite net charges or a charged object near a neutral polarizable body. The inference is conditional: complex conductors and charge distributions can behave differently. No visible motion alone cannot prove both neutral; support, weak forces or balancing forces can prevent motion.
4. Equal forces and different responses
FA = −FB; aA = FA/mA; aB = FB/mB
The mutual electrostatic forces have equal magnitudes even if charges and masses differ. Mass changes acceleration, not the equality of the pair forces. Other forces on a body can change its net acceleration. The two pair forces act on different bodies and do not cancel on either body’s free-body diagram.
5. Live particle model
Two point particles begin at rest 0.24 m apart. A has mass 1 g, B the selected mass; nC = 10⁻⁹ C and g = 10⁻³ kg. A velocity-Verlet calculation recomputes Coulomb force during each small time step. Twelve model seconds play over eight real seconds. At 0.08 m a declared catch stops the motion. The displayed electric accelerations are then contributions balanced by the catch, not net accelerations.
A zero-charge point particle has no internal structure and cannot polarize. It experiences zero force in this monopole-only model. This does not predict that real neutral paper or conductors fail to attract. Compare A charge with everything else fixed, then B mass with charges fixed. At equal separation, changing mass leaves electric force unchanged; subsequent trajectories can have different separations and therefore different forces.
6. Worked practice
A force on B of −0.018 N has the reaction +0.018 N on A. With mA = 0.006 kg, mB = 0.018 kg and FA = +0.054 N: FB = −0.054 N, aA = +9 m/s² and aB = −3 m/s². In the report, the reaction is +0.028 N; B remains neutral and polarizes, D is positive in the stated test, and mutual forces remain equal.
7. Scope
AP Physics 2 topic 10.1 includes electric forces and polarization. Cambridge A Level 9702 topic 18.3 covers point-charge force. The qualitative charge-test logic is supporting groundwork, rather than an additional named Cambridge assessment objective.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I assign attraction or repulsion from signs.
- I explain attraction of neutral polarizable bodies.
- I state the charge-test assumptions.
- I distinguish electric and net forces.
- I use equal opposite mutual forces.
- I distinguish force from acceleration.
— Crest ☆ “Infer charge cautiously and distinguish equal forces from equal accelerations.”
Mission 9.2 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Electric Force & Charge Interactions Master
A mutual force pair has equal magnitudes; observed attraction does not uniquely determine both net charges.