WONDER — The Mystery
Why Does the Hanging Mass Fall More Slowly?
A mass falls as a string unwinds from a fixed-axis drum. Gravity accelerates the mass downward, while tension pulls it upward. That same tension exerts a torque on the drum. How do the linear and rotational equations combine to determine an acceleration smaller than free fall?
Model: A rigid drum with fixed rotational inertia about a fixed frictionless axle. An ideal massless inextensible string unwinds without slipping, at a stated winding radius. A hanging point mass moves vertically. The string has sufficient length and the run ends before any impact. Gravity is uniform, g = 9.8 m/s². The lab chooses downward mass motion and CCW drum rotation as positive.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA fixed-axis rotor has inertia 0.50 kg·m². Its net torque is +1.5 N·m, with CCW positive. What is its angular acceleration?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
α = τnet/I = 1.5/0.50 = +3.0 rad/s². Use the net torque and inertia about the same axis.
▶ PLAY — Live Falling Mass and Rotating Drum
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two runs changing only drum inertia, then a third changing only hanging mass from one of that pair. Compare acceleration, tension and final speeds after the same 2 m fall. Try changing winding radius with inertia held fixed. Watch the mass descend while the drum’s persistent marker rotates.
The drum starts from rest, with specified inertia I and winding radius R. A mass m starts from rest and falls through 2.0 m; the measurement ends just before any impact. Massless string, no slip, no axle friction and g = 9.8 m/s². Downward translation and CCW rotation are positive. The duration is computed from the physical fall; each run is played over 8 real seconds. The independent I and R controls represent separately specified rotor and winding geometry. The winding circle uses 130 pixels/m; the mass descent uses 60 pixels/m. Force arrows on the mass share a per-run scale.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Drum Angular Velocity vs Physical Fall Time
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — The Law, the Axis and the Constraint
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Use net torque and fixed inertia
Click to flip
Use net torque and fixed inertia
Στexternal = Iα for a rigid body of fixed mass distribution about a fixed axis. Use torque and inertia about the same axis, and add all signed torques. For changing inertia, use the angular-momentum law instead of assuming this form unchanged.
Rule 2
Do both analyses when needed
Click to flip
Do both analyses when needed
The mass obeys mg − T = ma with downward positive. The drum obeys TR = Iα. The tension is not automatically mg when the mass accelerates. Linear force and rotational torque equations answer different parts of the coupled problem.
Rule 3
Link only with a stated constraint
Click to flip
Link only with a stated constraint
No slip of the massless inextensible string gives a = Rα and v = Rω with consistent signs. This link is tangential, not the total acceleration of a rim point. Constant-α integrated equations require constant net torque and fixed inertia.
Rule 4
Qualify the falling-stick result
Click to flip
Qualify the falling-stick result
For a uniform thin rod released horizontally from rest about a fixed end, the initial tip tangential acceleration is 3g/2 downward. Gravity’s torque changes as the rod turns, and inward acceleration appears as speed increases; the initial result is not valid throughout the fall.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “The tension of a string attached to a downward-accelerating hanging mass must equal its weight.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. With downward positive, mg − T = ma. For a > 0, tension is less than mg.
Myth 2: “The link a = Rα gives the total acceleration of every point on the rotating drum.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. It gives the tangential component at fixed radius. A moving rim point also has inward acceleration Rω².
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Net Torque and the Initial Falling Stick
DOK 2 — ApplyApply the stated axis, distribution and time conditions.
Instructor Q1 — A Force Through the Axle
A support force acts through a rotor’s fixed axle. How is it treated?
Instructor Q2 — Accelerating Hanging Mass
A hanging mass accelerates downward while attached to an ideal string. Compared with its weight, what is the tension?
Instructor Q3 — A Specified Rotor
A fixed-distribution rotor has inertia 0.60 kg·m² and net torque +1.8 N·m. Find its signed angular acceleration.
Instructor Q4 — Only the Release Instant
A uniform thin rod of length L is released horizontally from rest about one fixed end. Its end-axis inertia is mL²/3. Take g = 9.8 m/s². Find the initial tip tangential acceleration magnitude.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
The string tension is found from the combined dynamics, not guessed from the hanging weight.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Coupled Dynamics and Audit
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Opposing Torques
A rotor spinning counterclockwise has fixed inertia 0.30 kg·m². A +1.8 N·m drive torque acts together with a −0.30 N·m resisting torque. CCW is positive. Find its signed angular acceleration at this instant.
Step-by-Step Solution
Net torque = 1.8 − 0.30 = +1.50 N·m. α = 1.50/0.30 = +5.0 rad/s². It increases the initial positive angular velocity.
Challenge 2: A Mass Unwinds a Drum
A 1.2 kg hanging mass starts from rest on an ideal string unwinding without slip from a fixed-axis drum. The drum inertia is 0.18 kg·m² and winding radius is 0.30 m. Neglect axle friction and take g = 9.8 m/s². Downward mass motion and the corresponding rotation are positive. Find the mass acceleration, drum angular acceleration and string tension.
Step-by-Step Solution
Mass: mg − T = ma. Drum: TR = Iα. No slip: a = Rα, so T = Ia/R². Combining gives a = mg/(m + I/R²) = 11.76/(1.2 + 2.0) = 3.675 m/s².
α = a/R = 12.25 rad/s²; T = 1.2(9.8 − 3.675) = 7.35 N. This is less than the 11.76 N weight.
Challenge 3: Audit a Driven-Rotor Report
A fixed-axis rotor has inertia 0.80 kg·m², rim radius 0.40 m and initial angular velocity +2.0 rad/s. Constant torques are +6.0 N·m from a motor and −2.0 N·m from resistance for 2.0 s. CCW is positive. A report uses motor torque alone, labels the motion as slowing simply because a resisting torque exists, and takes the rim’s tangential acceleration as its total acceleration. Find net torque, signed angular acceleration, final angular velocity and final rim total acceleration magnitude. Explain all three errors with the directions of the rim acceleration components.
Step-by-Step Solution
τnet = 6.0 − 2.0 = +4.0 N·m, so α = 4.0/0.80 = +5.0 rad/s². Final ω = 2.0 + 5.0(2.0) = +12.0 rad/s. Using motor torque alone omits the resisting torque.
The net torque and angular velocity are both positive throughout, so the rotor speeds up despite the opposing contribution. Resistance alone does not determine the sign of α or whether speed decreases.
Final tangential magnitude = 0.40(5.0) = 2.0 m/s² and inward magnitude = 0.40(12.0)² = 57.6 m/s². They are perpendicular: total magnitude = √(2.0² + 57.6²) ≈ 57.634712 m/s². The tangential component is along the direction of rotation, while the inward component points toward the axle.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort the Coupled Equations by Their Role
DOK 2 — ApplySort the Coupled Equations by Their Role
The string is ideal, does not slip and connects the descending mass to the drum.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
A constraint is essential information, not an equation that can be imposed on every string or slipping contact.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why a hanging mass attached to an unwinding fixed-axis drum accelerates more slowly than g. Include tension’s two roles, the no-slip link and why force and torque equations are both needed.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 6.8 — Newton’s Second Law for Rotation
Use net torque. Connect rotation and translation.
1. Newton’s rotational law
Στexternal = Iα
This fixed-inertia form applies to a rigid body of fixed distribution about a fixed axis. Torque and inertia must refer to the same axis. Add torques with one convention; an opposing contribution is negative relative to a positive drive, but the resultant may still be positive.
For changing mass distribution, the general angular-momentum relation is needed. Do not carry the fixed-I form into tucking or other changing-I motion without checking its assumptions. The lab’s drum inertia stays fixed within each run.
2. Torque and force analyses coexist
Forces must be located correctly when their moments matter. An axle reaction acts through the axle and gives zero torque there, but it still supplies a real force. In uniform gravity an extended body’s weight can be represented at its center of gravity.
ΣF = MaCM describes translation; Στ = Iα describes the specified rotation. Saying that one must use torque “instead of” any force equation is misleading for systems with both kinds of motion. A hanging mass and drum require both analyses.
3. The hanging mass and fixed drum
mg − T = ma; TR = Iα; a = Rα
Downward translation and the corresponding drum rotation are positive. The rope is massless and inextensible, has sufficient length and does not slip at the winding surface. The axle has no frictional torque. Tension opposes the mass’s downward motion while driving rotation of the drum.
Eliminating tension gives a = mg/(m + I/R²). Then T = m(g − a) = Ia/R² and α = a/R. For positive finite I, m and R, acceleration lies between zero and g and tension lies between zero and mg. Increasing I at fixed m and R decreases the falling acceleration.
R is the winding radius, not necessarily a body’s outer radius. In the lab the drum’s specified I and winding geometry can be selected independently. If a shape model ties I to mass and radius, account for that relation before making a comparison.
4. Kinematics and rim acceleration
The lab’s m, I, R and g are constant, making a and α constant. Starting from rest, downward displacement is ½at², speed is at, angular velocity is αt and drum angle is displacement/R. A constant-acceleration time equation is valid because its dynamical assumptions were established.
At a fixed radius, tangential acceleration is Rα and inward acceleration is Rω². The no-slip string link uses the tangent direction. It does not mean a circular rim point has only that acceleration. At nonzero speed, combine the perpendicular tangential and inward components for total magnitude.
5. The falling-stick correction
A uniform thin rod released horizontally from rest about a fixed end has initial torque magnitude mgL/2 and end-axis inertia mL²/3. Its initial angular acceleration magnitude is 3g/(2L), and its tip initially has tangential acceleration 3g/2 downward.
This is an initial-instant result. As the rod turns, the gravity torque changes with its angle and the moving tip gains inward acceleration. It is incorrect to assert a constant 1.5g downward total acceleration throughout the motion.
At release, the CM acceleration is 3g/4 downward. The pivot therefore exerts an upward force mg/4 on the rod, while internal rigid-body forces distribute accelerations along its length. A tip acceleration greater than g does not violate Newton’s law or imply free fall of the whole rod.
6. Energy and the measurement boundary
With no dissipative losses, the hanging mass’s gravitational energy decrease becomes mass translational kinetic energy plus drum rotational kinetic energy: mg s = ½mv² + ½Iω². The drum’s axle is fixed, so its center does not gain translational kinetic energy.
The moving lab ends at a 2 m fall, just before any impact. The nonzero final speed is the measured incoming speed, not a claim that the mass physically stops without an interaction. An actual collision or rope-end stop would be another process outside this run.
7. Operate the live system
The mass descends while the persistent drum marker and spokes rotate CCW. The physical duration is calculated from the 2 m fall; each run is displayed over 8 real seconds. Winding radius uses 130 pixels/m and descent uses 60 pixels/m, clearly separate display scales. Mass force arrows use a shared per-run scale.
Run, pause, step and reset keep rotation and descent synchronized. Three matched completed runs change inertia alone, then mass alone. Compare final speeds at the same fall distance; comparing snapshots at equal elapsed time answers a different question. Preset loading earns no measured-trial credit.
8. Course scope
AP Physics 1 topic 5.6 covers net torque, inertia and angular acceleration, including the need for independent linear and rotational analyses. This mission’s fixed-axis rotational dynamics is extension for Cambridge A Level 9702. No multiple-plane rotation or quantitative slipping is included.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I sum all signed external torques about one axis.
- I state the fixed-inertia condition.
- I use force and torque equations where each applies.
- I find tension rather than equating it to weight.
- I state no slip before imposing the string link.
- I distinguish tangential from total rim acceleration.
- I qualify the initial falling-stick result.
— Crest ☆ “Use net torque. Connect rotation and translation.”
Mission 6.8 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Rotational Dynamics
The string tension is found from the combined dynamics, not guessed from the hanging weight.