WONDER — The Mystery
Why Might an Attachment Pull Down?
A rigid board is attached at its left end and supported farther to the right. A load sits on the overhanging end. A downward load to the right of the support tends to tip that end down. Can a downward force at the left attachment supply the opposing moment, while the right support pushes upward?
Model: Planar rigid-board statics in uniform gravity. A specified hold-down attachment can exert either upward or downward force; a simple contact support can push but cannot pull. All moment arms are measured from one chosen reference point. Rotational equilibrium alone permits constant angular velocity; static equilibrium additionally describes an object at rest with zero resultant force and moment.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA horizontal board has a hold-down attachment A at its left end and an upward support B to its right. Its own weight is negligible, and a downward load acts to the right of B. In static equilibrium, which direction must A’s force on the board have?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
About B, the load gives a clockwise moment. A downward force left of B gives a counterclockwise moment. B then pushes upward strongly enough to balance both downward forces.
▶ PLAY — Live Moving Load: Balanced Board Reactions
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two runs varying only moving-load weight, then a third varying only board weight from one of that pair. Watch a carriage travel across the board while the reactions update. Track the sign of A’s force and confirm both force and moment balance at every load position.
A uniform rigid board stays horizontal and at rest. Attachment A at x = 0 can push or pull vertically; support B at x = d pushes upward. An ideal carriage of constant weight moves at constant speed along a frictionless horizontal rail, from x = 0.1L to 0.9L in 4 physical seconds, displayed over 8 real seconds. Its horizontal speed is 0.2L m/s, and its vertical acceleration is zero, so its load on the board equals its weight. Start and stop transients are excluded. Support reactions vary with position; no stiffness or deflection is invented. Arrow lengths have one fixed scale within each run.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Conditions, Reference Points and Feasibility
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Complete static equilibrium
Click to flip
Complete static equilibrium
A body at rest remains in static equilibrium when ΣFx = 0, ΣFy = 0 and Στ = 0. These are balance conditions, not a claim that every such problem has three independent unknowns or a unique solution.
Rule 2
Rotational equilibrium can include motion
Click to flip
Rotational equilibrium can include motion
For a fixed-inertia rigid system, zero net torque means constant angular velocity, which may be nonzero. Translational equilibrium similarly permits constant CM velocity. Neither condition alone gives full static equilibrium.
Rule 3
Choose a reference to simplify moments
Click to flip
Choose a reference to simplify moments
In static equilibrium, take moments about any convenient point. A force through that point has zero moment there but remains in force balance. Choosing B removes B’s moment, not the moment of A at a different point.
Rule 4
Check support directions
Click to flip
Check support directions
A negative upward-positive reaction requires a downward force. A bolt or hold-down may supply it; a simple unilateral contact cannot. If a computed support reaction is impossible, the assumed static configuration is not feasible.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Zero resultant force is sufficient for a rigid body to be in static equilibrium.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A nonzero resultant moment can change rotation even when resultant force is zero. Static equilibrium requires both balances and initially stationary motion.
Myth 2: “Choosing a moment reference at one support eliminates every support force from all equations.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Only forces whose lines of action pass through that reference have zero moment there, and every support force still belongs in force balance.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Reference Points and Support Reactions
DOK 2 — ApplyUse force diagrams with application locations, then apply the appropriate static balance conditions.
Instructor Q1 — Why Choose the Hinge?
A stationary beam has two hinge-force components and a cable away from the hinge. Why is the hinge useful as a moment reference?
Instructor Q2 — Negative Contact Reaction
A static calculation requires a downward force from a support that can only push upward. What should be concluded?
Instructor Q3 — Balance a Lever
A horizontal massless lever has a 120 N downward load 0.75 m left of its support. A second downward load is 0.50 m right of that support. Find its weight for static balance.
Instructor Q4 — Complete Force Balance
A statically balanced beam receives a downward attachment force 240 N and total downward weight 360 N. Find the other support’s upward reaction.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
A smart moment reference simplifies algebra. It does not remove forces from the physical system or make an impossible support feasible.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Static Cases and Report Audit
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Balanced Uniform Stick
A uniform horizontal stick is 1.20 m long and supported at x = 0.30 m. A 3.6 N downward load acts at its left end x = 0. The stick is at rest in static equilibrium. Find the stick’s weight.
Step-by-Step Solution
The stick weight acts at x = 0.60 m. Both loads have 0.30 m arms on opposite sides of the support. Moment balance gives 3.6(0.30) = W(0.30), so W = 3.6 N.
Challenge 2: A Walker on a Bridge
A uniform 10 m horizontal bridge weighs 1200 N and is supported at both ends. A 400 N walker stands at x = 7.0 m from the left end. The bridge is in static equilibrium. Find the upward reaction of each support.
Step-by-Step Solution
Moments about the left end: 10RB − 1200(5) − 400(7) = 0, giving RB = 880 N. Force balance gives RA = 1200 + 400 − 880 = 720 N. Both reactions are upward and feasible for simple end supports.
Challenge 3: Audit an Overhang Report
A uniform horizontal board has length 4.5 m and weight 90 N. A 600 N load is at its right end. Hold-down attachment A is at x = 0; upward support B is at x = 1.5 m. The board is at rest. CCW moments and upward forces are positive. A report proposes RA = RB = +345 N, claiming zero net force proves equilibrium; says the board’s weight has zero moment because it is uniform; and says choosing B eliminates both support reactions. Find the correct signed reactions RA and RB, and the net moment about A for the report’s proposed reactions. Explain all three errors and why A must be a hold-down rather than a simple upward-only contact.
Step-by-Step Solution
About A: 1.5RB − 90(2.25) − 600(4.5) = 0. Thus RB = 1935 N. Vertical balance gives RA = 690 − 1935 = −1245 N, a downward attachment force.
The proposed reactions sum to 690 N, balancing total weight, but their net moment about A is 345(1.5) − 90(2.25) − 600(4.5) = −2385 N·m, not zero. Force balance alone is insufficient.
Uniform board weight acts at its midpoint x = 2.25 m and generally has a moment. About B, only RB has zero arm; RA acts 1.5 m left of B and remains in the moment equation. A downward RA is physically possible with the hold-down, while an upward-only simple contact at A cannot supply it.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort Balance Tests and Support Constraints
DOK 2 — ApplySort Balance Tests and Support Constraints
Classify statements about static planar problems and rotational equilibrium.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
An algebraic balance is useful only when the supports can supply the required forces.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why an overhanging board may need a downward left attachment and a larger upward interior support. Include both balance conditions, a useful moment reference and why a simple contact cannot replace a hold-down.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 6.6 — Rotational and Static Equilibrium
Balance forces and moments. Check the supports.
1. Static and rotational equilibrium
Static planar balance: ΣFx = 0; ΣFy = 0; Στ = 0
Static equilibrium describes an object at rest under these balances. Rotational equilibrium alone means zero resultant torque and constant angular velocity for a fixed-inertia rigid system; that velocity need not be zero. Translational equilibrium alone means constant CM velocity. Do not infer the full static condition from only one balance.
There can be up to three independent planar balance equations, but a particular force geometry may give fewer independent equations. More unknown support components can require additional information, such as material deformation. Equilibrium does not automatically solve every collection of three unknowns.
2. Draw forces at their locations
Include every external force on the chosen object: weights, support reactions, cable tension and applied loads. A uniform board’s weight acts at its midpoint in uniform gravity. An attached load acts at its stated location, not automatically at the midpoint.
For angled cable forces, use the perpendicular component in moments and both components in force balance. The cable’s angle reference matters. A hinge force through a chosen hinge reference has zero moment there, but still contributes to horizontal and vertical force balance.
3. Choose a useful moment reference
In static equilibrium, the net moment is zero about any reference point. Choose one that removes a troublesome force’s moment by placing the reference on its line of action. The physical force does not cancel or disappear; its moment arm is zero at that reference.
If A and B are different support points, choosing B removes B’s moment, not A’s. Forces at A usually have a nonzero arm about B. Check that all terms in one moment equation use the same reference. When net force is nonzero, zero torque about one point does not automatically mean zero torque about every point.
4. Overhanging-board reactions
For a uniform horizontal board of length L, weight Wb, a downward load Wc at coordinate x, attachment A at zero and support B at d:
RB = [Wb(L/2) + Wc x]/d; RA = Wb + Wc − RB
These formulas follow from moments about A and vertical balance. Reactions are upward-positive. RB is positive in this model; RA can change sign as the load passes farther beyond B. A negative RA is a downward pull on the board, not an arithmetic error or a value to replace by its absolute magnitude.
About B, a downward load to its right creates a clockwise moment. A downward attachment force to its left can provide a counterclockwise moment. The upward B reaction then balances all downward forces.
5. Support feasibility
A simple support contact pushes in its allowed normal direction and cannot pull the object toward itself after losing contact. A bolt or hold-down can provide the downward reaction needed by an overhang. A cable can pull along its length, but cannot push in compression.
If the equations demand an unavailable force, the proposed static geometry fails. The object may lift off a support or change configuration; additional attachments can supply the missing interaction. Do not keep an impossible reaction just because the algebra balances.
6. The live moving-load experiment
The board stays rigid, horizontal and stationary; the carriage actually moves. It travels from 0.1L to 0.9L at constant horizontal speed 0.2L m/s during the 4 physical-second interval. Its vertical acceleration is zero and the rail is frictionless, so its vertical load equals its weight while its horizontal velocity remains constant.
The support reactions are recalculated at every carriage position, and both net force and net moment are zero for the board throughout. The changing sign of RA shows when a downward attachment force becomes necessary. Reaction arrows change direction and magnitude with one consistent per-run scale.
No flexural stiffness, damping or invented relaxation angle is used. Elastic bending would require an additional material model, which is not specified here. Beginning or ending the carriage motion involves external control and is excluded; this run is the steady-speed interval.
Run, pause, step and reset synchronize the moving carriage and readouts. Three matched completed runs isolate carriage weight and board weight. Loading a preset alone does not complete a measured trial.
7. Course scope and independent reasoning
Cambridge AS Level 9702 4.2 covers the principle of moments and combined force/torque equilibrium. AP Physics 1 5.5 distinguishes rotational equilibrium from translational equilibrium and permits constant angular velocity. This mission uses one plane only.
Check signs, support type, weight locations and both balances before judging a report. A plausible resultant force is not enough; verify the moments with the proposed reactions. A uniform board has a definite weight location, not a weight that can be omitted.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I distinguish static from rotational equilibrium.
- I include all weights at their correct locations.
- I use one moment reference consistently.
- I keep zero-arm forces in force balance.
- I test both resultant force and resultant moment.
- I interpret negative reactions physically.
- I check what each support can supply.
— Crest ☆ “Balance forces and moments. Check the supports.”
Mission 6.6 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Equilibrium
A smart moment reference simplifies algebra. It does not remove forces from the physical system or make an impossible support feasible.