WONDER — The Mystery
A Smooth Path Through Complicated Motion
A rigid object can rotate while moving, so its different points trace different paths. Its center of mass follows a simpler motion governed by the resultant external force. With no net external force its CM may move uniformly; under uniform gravity alone it follows projectile motion. Which mass-weighted point should we track?
Model: Each compact part is represented by its own center of mass. Quantitative examples use constant total mass. Horizontal raft examples neglect horizontal external forces. Center of gravity coincides with CM in a uniform gravitational field. Stability claims assume a stationary rigid object under gravity and support reactions, with no other overturning forces.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictTwo point masses lie on a line: 3 kg at x = 0 m and 9 kg at x = 8 m. Where is the center of mass?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
xCM = [3(0) + 9(8)]/(3 + 9) = 6 m. Its distances from the masses are 6 m and 2 m, the inverse ratio of their masses.
▶ PLAY — Live Dumbbell: Rotation Around a Moving CM
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two runs changing only mass 1, then a third changing only separation from one of that pair. Watch both masses rotate while the gold CM moves along a straight line. Compare the CM with the gray geometric midpoint and check the mass-weighted coordinates throughout each run.
Two point masses joined by a massless rigid rod on an ideal frictionless horizontal plane. Internal rod forces hold separation L constant. No net external force acts in the plane. The initial CM velocity is +0.40 m/s horizontally, and angular velocity is a constant 1 rad/s CCW. The CM starts at (0,0). A run lasts 3 physical seconds over 8 real seconds. Position scale is 60 pixels/m; marker sizes are schematic. Gold is the instantaneous CM, gray the midpoint. Gravity and the plane’s normal reactions cancel vertically.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Location, Motion and Gravity
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Use a mass-weighted position
Click to flip
Use a mass-weighted position
xCM = Σ(mi xi)/Σmi; apply the same equation independently to y. Use consistent signed coordinates and count every included mass. An extended component contributes at its own CM; area represents mass only for equal uniform areal density.
Rule 2
Zero external force gives constant velocity
Click to flip
Zero external force gives constant velocity
For constant total mass, ΣFexternal = M aCM. Internal forces cannot change total CM acceleration. If external force is zero, CM velocity remains constant; CM stays fixed only if that velocity is initially zero.
Rule 3
CM and center of gravity
Click to flip
CM and center of gravity
The center of gravity is the effective point of resultant weight. It coincides with CM in a uniform gravitational field. Geometric symmetry identifies CM only when the mass distribution has the same symmetry. CM can lie in empty space.
Rule 4
Use qualified stability reasoning
Click to flip
Use qualified stability reasoning
For a stationary rigid body under gravity on a support, the vertical line through its center of gravity must lie within the support region to avoid gravity-driven tipping. At an edge it is a limiting case. Other external forces or motion require additional force and moment analysis.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “With no net external force, a system’s center of mass must stay fixed.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Its velocity stays constant. A CM initially moving continues moving; only an initially stationary CM stays fixed.
Myth 2: “The CM must lie inside the material and must equal the geometric midpoint.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A uniform ring’s CM is in its hole, and an unequal two-mass system has its CM away from the geometric midpoint.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Weighted Position and Raft Motion
DOK 2 — ApplyFor raft motion, treat person plus raft as one system and examine only the horizontal external-force condition.
Instructor Q1 — Select the System
A person walks on a floating raft. For the person-plus-raft system, how are the contact forces between them classified?
Instructor Q2 — A Moving Isolated CM
A constant-mass system has zero net external force and initial CM velocity +0.6 m/s. What happens to CM velocity?
Instructor Q3 — A Weighted Coordinate
Two masses are 2 kg at x = −1 m and 6 kg at x = 3 m. Find xCM.
Instructor Q4 — A Stationary Raft System
A 20 kg person moves 3.0 m right relative to a 60 kg raft. The combined CM is initially at rest and no horizontal external force acts. Find the signed raft displacement, with right positive.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
The CM is computed from simultaneous mass positions; it is not a particle that is pulled toward the heavier mass by an invented force.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent CM and System-Motion Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Two Signed Positions
Two point masses lie on one line: 1.5 kg at x = −2.0 m and 4.5 kg at x = +2.0 m. Find the center-of-mass coordinate.
Step-by-Step Solution
xCM = [1.5(−2.0) + 4.5(2.0)]/(1.5 + 4.5) = 6/6 = +1.0 m. It lies between the masses and closer to the 4.5 kg mass.
Challenge 2: Three Masses in a Plane
Three point masses are 2 kg at (−1,0) m, 3 kg at (3,4) m and 5 kg at (5,−2) m. Find both coordinates of their center of mass.
Step-by-Step Solution
Total mass = 10 kg. xCM = [2(−1) + 3(3) + 5(5)]/10 = 32/10 = 3.2 m. yCM = [2(0) + 3(4) + 5(−2)]/10 = 2/10 = 0.2 m.
Challenge 3: Audit a Moving Raft Report
A 24 kg person begins at the left end x = 0 of a uniform 72 kg raft of length 6.0 m, initially centered at x = 3.0 m. The combined initial CM velocity is +0.40 m/s. The person reaches the right end after 5.0 s. No horizontal external force acts; right is positive. A report uses an unweighted midpoint for the initial CM, says the CM stays fixed because the forces are internal, and sets the person’s ground displacement equal to the raft length. Find initial and final CM coordinates, signed raft displacement and signed person ground displacement. Explain all three report errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Initial xCM = [24(0) + 72(3)]/96 = 2.25 m. With zero horizontal external force, CM velocity remains +0.40 m/s, so final xCM = 2.25 + 0.40(5.0) = 4.25 m.
Let the raft displacement be d. Its center becomes 3 + d and the person’s coordinate becomes 6 + d. Thus [24(6 + d) + 72(3 + d)]/96 = 4.25, giving d = +0.50 m. Person ground displacement is 6 + d = +6.50 m.
Use a mass-weighted average, not the simple midpoint. Internal interactions preserve the CM velocity here, not its position, because it starts moving. The 6 m walking displacement is relative to the raft; ground displacement includes the raft’s displacement.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort Location, Motion and Stability Claims
DOK 2 — ApplySort Location, Motion and Stability Claims
Each statement includes the conditions needed for its category.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
A weighted geometric definition, a dynamical law and a stability condition answer different questions.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why an unequal two-mass object rotates around a point closer to its heavier mass while that center can move in a straight line. State the external-force condition, and explain when the center of gravity equals the center of mass.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 6.5 — Center of Mass and Center of Gravity
A weighted position. Motion set by external force.
1. Mass-weighted position
xCM = Σ(mi xi)/Σmi; yCM = Σ(mi yi)/Σmi
Use coordinates measured from a common origin at the same instant. Positions may be negative. Divide every coordinate numerator by the same total included mass. An arithmetic midpoint is correct for two equal masses, but unequal masses require weights.
For two masses, the CM lies between them and nearer the heavier mass. Their distances satisfy m1 d1 = m2 d2. This geometric definition does not imply a physical “tug of war” that moves a CM marker while the masses remain fixed.
2. Extended objects and empty space
Represent an extended component by its mass located at its own CM when computing the combined CM. A uniform rod’s CM is at its midpoint. For laminae, use area in place of mass only when thickness and density give the same uniform mass per area. Subtracting a hole requires subtracting its mass and weighted position, not simply averaging the remaining visible corners.
Symmetry of mass distribution identifies CM. A geometric shape with nonuniform density need not have its CM at its geometric center. A ring has its CM in its central hole, showing that CM need not lie within material.
3. The center-of-mass law
ΣFexternal = M aCM, for constant total mass
Internal action–reaction pairs cancel in the total force sum. They may rearrange constituents, but they do not change the combined CM acceleration. If net external force is zero, CM velocity stays constant. It stays at a fixed position only when that initial CM velocity is zero.
During an isolated collision or explosion, the system CM may keep moving. Under uniform gravity alone, its horizontal motion is uniform and vertical motion has acceleration g, so the projectile path is parabolic when there is nonzero horizontal velocity. Drag, nonuniform fields or other external forces change that model.
4. Relative motion on a raft
For a person and raft with negligible horizontal external force, total horizontal momentum and CM velocity remain constant. If both initially have zero combined CM velocity, their weighted horizontal displacements sum to zero.
A walking displacement relative to the raft is not generally the person’s ground displacement. If raft displacement is d and walking displacement relative to it is ℓ, the person’s ground displacement is d + ℓ. Include both in the CM equation. If CM initially moves at V, its ground displacement over time t is Vt rather than zero.
Gravity and buoyancy are external forces, so the raft system is not entirely free of external force. The simplified conservation condition concerns the horizontal resultant. Water resistance, wind or a push from shore can invalidate it.
5. Center of gravity
The center of gravity is the effective point through which resultant weight acts for moment calculations. It equals the center of mass when the gravitational field has the same direction and strength across the system. In a nonuniform field this equality is not automatic.
The center of gravity can be found experimentally for a lamina by suspending it from different points and finding the intersection of vertical plumb lines. In uniform gravity this locates its CM as well.
6. Static stability is conditional
For a resting rigid body supported against gravity, a weight line strictly inside the support region allows support reactions to balance it without gravity-driven tipping. At the edge the system is at a tipping threshold. Outside, the weight tends to overturn it about the nearest support edge unless another interaction prevents this.
A wider base or lower center of gravity usually increases the tipping angle for the same basic geometry. The inside-base condition is not a universal guarantee against tipping under external pushes, acceleration or large initial motion. A tightrope pole mainly increases rotational inertia; holding it low or allowing its ends to droop may also lower the combined CM.
7. The live dumbbell
The massless rod fixes separation L. Distances from CM are d1 = m2L/(m1 + m2) and d2 = m1L/(m1 + m2), so the heavier side has the shorter rotation radius. Both points rotate at 1 rad/s about the instantaneous CM while the CM moves right at 0.40 m/s.
The gold CM follows the straight horizontal path required by zero net in-plane external force. The gray midpoint rotates with the rod and generally does not coincide with CM for unequal masses. Equal masses make them coincide throughout. The displayed instantaneous coordinates always reproduce the gold marker through the weighted-average formula.
Run, pause, step and reset show 3 physical seconds over 8 real seconds. Three matched completed setups isolate a mass change and a separation change. This is actual motion of the masses with the CM recomputed at each instant, replacing the artificial animation that moved only a CM marker toward its final answer.
8. Course boundary
AP Physics 1 topic 2.1 directly covers systems and quantitative CM for up to five particles in two dimensions or highly symmetrical systems. Newton’s second law supplies the CM-motion interpretation. Cambridge AS Level 9702 4.1 includes center of gravity; these general weighted CM calculations and moving-system examples are extension rather than a prescribed Cambridge calculation objective.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I use a mass-weighted average at one instant.
- I preserve the origin and coordinate signs.
- I include each extended component at its own CM.
- I distinguish constant CM velocity from fixed CM position.
- I check the net external-force condition for the chosen direction.
- I separate raft-relative and ground motion.
- I qualify center-of-gravity and stability claims.
— Crest ☆ “A weighted position. Motion set by external force.”
Mission 6.5 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Center of Mass
The CM is computed from simultaneous mass positions; it is not a particle that is pulled toward the heavier mass by an invented force.