WONDER — The Mystery
A Faster Spin Without External Torque
A skater pulls her arms inward and spins faster. During the short tuck, the net external torque about her spin axis is negligible. Her mass distribution changes, and her muscles do work. Which rotational quantity stays constant, and where does the extra kinetic energy come from?
Model: One fixed vertical axis in an inertial frame; CCW is positive. For a rotating system whose constituents share an angular velocity, L = Iω about that axis. Internal interactions can redistribute angular momentum between constituents and transfer internal energy into kinetic energy. Conservation of total angular momentum requires zero net external torque throughout the interval, not a guarantee of constant angular velocity or kinetic energy.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA diver changes body shape while in the air. Net external torque about the chosen spin axis is negligible. Her moment of inertia becomes one third of its initial value. What happens to her angular velocity?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
With the same axis and negligible external angular impulse, initial Iω equals final Iω. Reducing inertia by a factor of three increases angular velocity by a factor of three, with the same sign. Kinetic energy need not stay constant.
▶ PLAY — Live Tuck: Radial Motion and a Changing Spin
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Complete two runs that differ only in final radius. Then change only initial angular velocity from one of that pair. Measure three matched runs. Watch both masses slide while the guide rotates. Compare the evolving inertia and spin with the constant total angular momentum and changing kinetic energy.
Two equal point masses slide along opposite massless radial guides attached to a rotating core. The core, guides, masses and internal actuators form the selected system. The core has fixed inertia 0.20 kg·m². A frictionless vertical axle supplies no axial torque; gravity and support supply no torque about that axis. Internal actuators maintain constant radial speed from the selected initial radius to final radius during a 2-physical-second measurement interval, played over 8 real seconds. The measurement starts after radial motion has begun and ends before it is stopped; endpoint actuator transients are excluded. All parts share the same instantaneous angular velocity. The integrated angle drives the actual guides and mass positions; CCW is positive. Scale: 100 pixels per meter.
Status: Ready
Playback: 8 real seconds per run; read elapsed physical model time. Pause or Step for measurements.
Angular Velocity vs Physical Time
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — System, Condition, Spin and Energy
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Choose the system and axis
Click to flip
Choose the system and axis
Total angular momentum is the sum of the constituents’ signed angular momenta about the same specified inertial axis. An interaction is internal only if both interacting objects belong to the chosen system.
Rule 2
Use the net external torque
Click to flip
Use the net external torque
Zero net external torque throughout an interval keeps total L constant throughout it. External forces may exist and still give zero net torque about the chosen axis. A pivot force has zero moment about that pivot.
Rule 3
Changing inertia changes spin
Click to flip
Changing inertia changes spin
For common-axis rotation, initial Iω = final Iω when external angular impulse is zero. Reducing I increases |ω| for nonzero L. With variable I, zero torque does not imply zero angular acceleration; d(Iω)/dt = 0.
Rule 4
Momentum conservation is not energy conservation
Click to flip
Momentum conservation is not energy conservation
At fixed nonzero L, rotational kinetic energy is L²/(2I). A tuck can increase it through internal work using stored energy. Internal friction can instead reduce kinetic energy while preserving the selected system’s total angular momentum.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Angular momentum is conserved only during collisions.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. The condition is zero net external torque for continuous conservation, independent of the event’s name. A tuck, internal rearrangement or collision can qualify. An explosion in an external field must still be checked for external torque or angular impulse; conservation is not automatic.
Myth 2: “Conserved angular momentum guarantees conserved kinetic energy.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. A skater can use internal stored energy to raise kinetic energy while keeping L constant. Internal friction in coupled rotors can lower kinetic energy without changing the pair’s total L.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Conservation Conditions and Applications
DOK 2 — ApplyState the system and reference axis before calculating. Distinguish a conserved total from a constituent’s changing value.
Instructor Q1 — The Conservation Condition
Which condition guarantees constant total angular momentum throughout an interval about a fixed inertial axis?
Instructor Q2 — One Rotor or Both?
Two coaxial rotors exchange torque through internal friction. The pair has no net external torque. Which angular momentum must stay constant?
Instructor Q3 — A Fresh Tuck
A skater initially has I = 2.50 kg·m² and ω = +1.20 rad/s. With negligible external angular impulse, final inertia is 0.75 kg·m². Find final signed angular velocity.
Instructor Q4 — An Ideal Central-Force Orbit
An ideal point-mass satellite has speed 6.0 km/s at an apsis 2.0 × 10⁷ m from a fixed central source. At the other apsis its distance is 5.0 × 10⁷ m. Velocity is perpendicular to radius at both apsides. Find the other-apsis speed in km/s.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Zero net external torque preserves total angular momentum. Changing shape can still change angular velocity and kinetic energy.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Tuck, Impact and Energy Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Shape Change
A rotating body has initial inertia 2.40 kg·m² and initial angular velocity +1.50 rad/s. It changes shape to final inertia 0.80 kg·m² with negligible net external angular impulse. Find final signed angular velocity about the same axis.
Step-by-Step Solution
Initial L = 2.40(1.50) = +3.60 kg·m²/s. Final ω = 3.60/0.80 = +4.50 rad/s. The inertia is reduced by three, so the nonzero angular velocity increases by three.
Challenge 2: A Dart Sticks to a Pivoted Rod
A stationary rod rotates in a horizontal plane about a frictionless vertical pivot. Its inertia about that pivot is 0.090 kg·m². A 0.120 kg point-mass dart travels at 8.0 m/s perpendicular to the rod and sticks 0.50 m from the pivot, giving CCW motion. The rod and dart form the selected system; net external angular impulse about the pivot is zero during impact. Find their final total inertia, final angular velocity, final rotational kinetic energy and decrease in kinetic energy.
Step-by-Step Solution
The dart adds mr² = 0.120(0.50)² = 0.030 kg·m², so final I = 0.090 + 0.030 = 0.120 kg·m². Initial L = rmv = 0.50(0.120)(8.0) = +0.480 kg·m²/s.
Final ω = 0.480/0.120 = +4.00 rad/s and final K = ½(0.120)(4.00)² = 0.960 J. Initial K = ½(0.120)(8.0)² = 3.840 J, so 2.880 J is transferred from kinetic energy into other forms during sticking.
The pivot can exert an external force and change linear momentum while supplying zero torque about the pivot. The dart’s pre-impact angular momentum is already angular momentum; linear momentum does not turn into a different conserved quantity.
Challenge 3: Audit a Skater’s Energy Report
A skater starts with inertia 3.60 kg·m² and angular velocity +1.50 rad/s. She tucks to inertia 1.20 kg·m². Net external torque about the spin axis is negligible. The initial and final shapes are steady; assume no change in translational kinetic energy or gravitational potential energy. A report calls the muscle interactions external torques because the forces are nonzero, keeps angular velocity unchanged because net external torque is zero, and keeps rotational kinetic energy unchanged because angular momentum is conserved. Calculate final angular velocity, initial and final rotational kinetic energies, and internal work added to rotational motion. Explain all three errors and identify the energy source.
Step-by-Step Solution
Initial L = 3.60(1.50) = +5.40 kg·m²/s. Final ω = 5.40/1.20 = +4.50 rad/s. Initial K = ½(3.60)(1.50)² = 4.05 J; final K = ½(1.20)(4.50)² = 12.15 J.
Internal work added to rotation = ΔK = 12.15 − 4.05 = +8.10 J. Stored chemical energy in the skater supplies this increase; total energy is accounted for when that store is included.
Muscle interactions are internal to the selected whole-skater system, even though their forces are nonzero. Internal torques exchange angular momentum between body parts without changing the total. Zero net external torque preserves Iω, not ω alone when I changes. Conserved L does not require conserved K: here lowering I raises K = L²/(2I). Internal work can change kinetic energy without external angular impulse.
☷ CHALLENGE — Sort the System, Conservation and Energy Claims
DOK 2 — ApplySort the System, Conservation and Energy Claims
Classify each statement. Select a card, then its category; keyboard and touch both work.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
An internal torque may change one constituent’s momentum while preserving the total; an internal energy transfer may change kinetic energy without external torque.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain to a younger learner why a skater speeds up when she pulls her arms inward. State the selected system and the external-torque condition, explain the inertia–angular-velocity trade, and say where the increased kinetic energy comes from.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 6.11 — Conservation of Angular Momentum
Choose the system. Preserve its momentum. Account for its energy.
1. Define the selected system and axis
Total angular momentum is the sum of each constituent’s angular momentum about the same chosen inertial axis. CCW-positive planar signs provide consistent bookkeeping. An interaction is internal only when both interacting objects are included in the system.
Net external torque = rate of change of total angular momentum
Zero net external torque throughout an interval means total L is constant throughout it. The condition concerns the net torque, not absence of every external force or every individual torque. Several external torques can cancel. A force applied at the chosen pivot has zero moment about it.
Zero net external angular impulse over an interval ensures equal endpoint angular momenta. It does not necessarily imply L stayed constant between those endpoints, because positive and negative impulses might cancel.
2. Internal interactions and subsystems
Ordinary internal contact torques exchange angular momentum between constituents and cancel in the total for the full mechanical system. They need not vanish separately. Two rotors can exchange angular momentum through friction: the pair’s total L is constant if external torque is zero, while each rotor’s L changes.
If only one rotor is selected, the other rotor’s contact torque is external to that subsystem. “Friction destroys angular momentum” is therefore inaccurate; identify the system and the torque instead. Friction may convert kinetic energy into internal energy even when total angular momentum is conserved.
3. A tuck changes inertia and spin
Common-axis rotation: L = Iω; zero angular impulse: Iiωi = Ifωf
The inertia refers to the same axis at both times. Moving mass inward reduces the sum of mr². For nonzero constant L, smaller inertia requires a proportionally larger angular-velocity magnitude, with the same rotation sign. Moving mass outward does the reverse. Zero initial L stays zero in this common-rotation model; radial motion alone creates no total L.
For a nonrigid system with changing inertia, zero external torque does not imply zero angular acceleration. The rate equation is d(Iω)/dt = Iα + (dI/dt)ω. The shortcut τ = Iα applies when I is fixed. A changing shape can have α ≠ 0 with zero net external torque.
4. Momentum and energy are separate accounts
Krot = ½Iω² = L²/(2I), for the common-axis rotation
At the same nonzero L, reducing I increases rotational kinetic energy. A skater’s muscles do internal work using stored chemical energy. Zero external torque does not forbid internal work. Total energy is accounted for when changes in internal stores and other forms are included; rotational kinetic energy alone need not be conserved.
In the practice skater case, L = 5.40 kg·m²/s, final ω = 4.50 rad/s, and K rises from 4.05 J to 12.15 J. The increase, 8.10 J, comes from internal work. The whole skater’s muscle interactions are internal; nonzero forces do not make them external.
5. Collision about a pivot
A dart already has angular momentum about a pivot before impact, found from its momentum and perpendicular arm. In a sticking collision, add the dart’s mr² to the rod’s supplied pivot inertia. Preserve total L only after checking external angular impulse about that pivot.
A pivot force may change the system’s linear momentum but has zero torque about the pivot. In the horizontal-plane model gravity and support do not provide torque about the vertical spin axis. Sticking generally reduces kinetic energy. Total energy is accounted for in internal energy, deformation and other transfers; kinetic energy is not preserved just because L is.
For the practice dart, initial L = 0.480 kg·m²/s and final I = 0.120 kg·m². Final ω = 4.00 rad/s; final K = 0.960 J versus initial K = 3.840 J. The kinetic-energy decrease is 2.880 J.
6. Central-force orbital motion
A central force gives zero torque about its center. In the ideal fixed-source model, a point mass’s angular-momentum magnitude is mrvperp = mr² times angular speed. The radial velocity component contributes zero angular momentum about that center.
General: r1vperp1 = r2vperp2; at two apsides: r1v1 = r2v2
At periapsis and apoapsis, velocity is perpendicular to radius, so its full speed equals the transverse component. Radius times full speed is not generally constant at other orbital positions. Equal swept area in equal times follows from constant angular momentum for fixed mass; this does not imply uniform speed.
The drill uses fresh ideal-orbit data, not an unverified numerical claim about a named comet. Orbital total energy can be constant while kinetic energy changes as gravitational potential energy changes.
7. The actual live radial model
Core inertia is fixed at Ic = 0.20 kg·m². Two equal point masses m occupy opposite radii r and share the core’s angular velocity. The selected system includes the actuators; no net external torque acts about the fixed vertical axis.
I(t) = Ic + 2mr(t)²; L = Iinitialωinitial; ω(t) = L/I(t)
The radial position changes at constant speed during a 2-physical-second measurement interval. The animation integrates this varying ω to give the guides’ actual angle; it does not interpolate I and ω independently. A tuck increases |ω|, an extension reduces it, a fixed radius gives uniform spin, and a clockwise tuck remains clockwise.
Radial kinetic energy of the two masses is m times radial speed squared and is constant within this interval. Rotational kinetic energy changes with I. The total kinetic-energy change therefore equals the displayed rotational-energy change, supplied or absorbed by internal actuators. Starting and stopping the radial motion would require separate energy accounting; those transients are outside the interval.
Each run plays 2 physical seconds over 8 real seconds. Pause, step and reset inspect the same physical state. Mass positions use 100 pixels per meter. Load two final-radius setups with other controls fixed, then change only initial angular velocity from one of them. Three distinct matched completed runs unlock the next stage; merely loading givens earns no credit.
8. Course scope and the chapter’s conclusion
AP Physics 1 topic 6.4 directly covers angular-momentum conservation, the selected system, internal interactions and changes of shape. Angular momentum is extension for Cambridge A Level 9702. The radial model’s exact integration supports faithful simulation; memorizing that calculus is not required. Formal three-dimensional direction-vector calculations are excluded.
Chapter 6 connects angular motion, torque, inertia, equilibrium, Newton’s rotational law, energy, angular impulse and conservation. Each model must state its axis, system and conditions before choosing an equation.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I define the system and reference axis.
- I check net external torque or angular impulse.
- I distinguish the total L from a constituent’s L.
- I include all post-impact inertia contributions.
- I preserve Iω when inertia changes.
- I apply τ = Iα only for fixed inertia.
- I account separately for kinetic and internal energy.
- I use full orbital speed in rv only where it is perpendicular to r.
— Crest ☆ “Choose the system. Preserve its momentum. Account for its energy.”
Mission 6.11 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Angular Momentum Conservation
Zero net external torque preserves total angular momentum. Changing shape can still change angular velocity and kinetic energy.