WONDER — The Mystery
The Swing That Gets Lower
A swing reaches a turning point, moves fastest near the bottom, then reaches a lower turning point on the next side. Where did the decrease in mechanical energy go? What changes when we include air, bearings and their thermal energy in a larger system?
Model: Choose a system before adding its energy. Mechanical energy is kinetic plus the potential energies of interactions included in that system. These numerical tasks use translation, uniform g = 9.8 N/kg and specified ideal springs. Rotation, deformation beyond the spring model and relativistic effects are excluded.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA 3 kg sliding particle starts at rest 4 m above a ramp’s foot. Take gravitational U = 0 at the foot. The Earth–particle system has no dissipative interaction or external work; the fixed normal support does zero work. What is K at the foot?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
Initial K = 0 and U = 3 × 9.8 × 4 = 117.6 J. At the foot U = 0, so K = 117.6 J. Conservation of mechanical energy follows from the specified conditions.
▶ PLAY — Ramp Energy and a Resisting Brake
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Measure two release heights at the same mass, angle, resistance and initial speed. Then change only the resistance from one of that pair. Compare three matched setups. Explore a release from rest, a moving start, an early stop and a brake that holds at rest.
A particle moves down a straight fixed ramp in uniform gravity. While sliding, a brake opposes motion with the chosen constant resistance R. At rest the ideal brake can hold with any force up to R; if the downhill gravity component exceeds R, sliding starts. The normal force does zero work. End is the ramp foot or the exact first stop, whichever comes first. Earth–body mechanical energy decreases by brake work; for the enlarged isolated Earth–body–brake system, that decrease becomes thermal energy. No other transfers or stores are included.
Status: Ready
Playback: 4 simulation seconds per real second. Pause or Step for measurements.
Mechanical and Thermal Energy Ledger
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Conservation Requires a Complete Ledger
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Choose the system and stores
Click to flip
Choose the system and stores
Mechanical energy is Emech = K + U, with all relevant potential stores included. Gravity U belongs to Earth and body; spring U belongs to the deformed spring system. A rolling object may also have rotational K.
Rule 2
State conservation conditions
Click to flip
State conservation conditions
Mechanical energy is constant when net external work is zero and no internal dissipative interactions convert mechanical energy to other stores. “No friction” alone is insufficient if, for example, a motor transfers energy into the chosen system.
Rule 3
Track dissipation without destruction
Click to flip
Track dissipation without destruction
For Earth and body on a resisted ramp, negative brake work lowers K + Ug. Include the brake in a larger isolated system: mechanical decrease is balanced by thermal increase in this model. Energy does not disappear.
Rule 4
Distinguish net work and mechanical change
Click to flip
Distinguish net work and mechanical change
For the translating particle, net force work equals ΔK. For the Earth–body system, gravity’s transfer is already represented by ΔUg, so brake work gives Δ(K + Ug) in this lab. Counting both gravity work and the same potential change again would double count.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “Whenever there is no friction, the chosen system’s mechanical energy must stay constant even if a motor does work on it.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. External motor work can increase mechanical energy. State the system boundary and all transfers, as well as the absence of dissipation.
Myth 2: “If mechanical energy decreases during braking, that amount of total energy has been destroyed.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. In the enlarged isolated model, the mechanical decrease becomes thermal energy. Other real systems may also transfer energy to sound or surroundings; include them in the ledger.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — System Boundary and Model Limits
DOK 2 — ApplyIdentify which sum is being conserved. Energy accounting can predict a speed, but extra dynamical constraints may still need checking.
Instructor Q1 — External Motor Work
A motor does positive work on a selected mechanical system. There is no dissipation and no other transfer. What happens to that system’s mechanical energy?
Instructor Q2 — Loop Contact
An energy calculation gives a positive speed at the top of a vertical loop. Is that fact alone enough to guarantee an unrestrained particle stays in contact with the inside of the track?
Instructor Q3 — Add the Stores
In a stated system and reference, K = 40 J and Ug = 60 J. No other mechanical store is present. Find Emech.
Instructor Q4 — Add an External Transfer
A system starts with mechanical energy 100 J. External work of +35 J is done on it; there is no dissipation or other energy transfer. Find its final mechanical energy.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Mechanical energy can decrease, increase or stay constant. Total energy accounting depends on included stores and energy crossing the selected boundary.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Mechanical-Energy Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: An Ideal Slide
A sliding particle starts from rest 3.20 m above a ramp’s foot. In the Earth–particle system, uniform g = 9.8 N/kg acts with no dissipative interaction or external work. The stationary ramp’s normal force does zero work. Find the speed at the foot; rotation is excluded.
Step-by-Step Solution
With no dissipation or external work, mg(3.20) = ½mv². Hence v² = 62.72 m²/s² and speed ≈ 7.920 m/s. Mass cancels in this particular ideal translation model.
Challenge 2: An Ideal Spring Release
A 1.40 kg block is attached to an ideal spring with k = 280 N/m on a smooth horizontal surface. It starts at rest with spring deformation −0.25 m. The block–spring system has no dissipative interaction or external work. At the first passage through the undeformed position, find the block’s kinetic energy and speed. Neglect rotation and spring mass.
Step-by-Step Solution
Initial elastic U = ½ × 280 × 0.25² = 8.75 J. At x = 0, spring U = 0 and K = 8.75 J. Speed = √(2 × 8.75/1.40) = √12.5 ≈ 3.536 m/s.
Challenge 3: Audit the Energy Ledger
A 6 kg translating body moves from height 8 m at speed 2 m/s to height 3 m at speed 8 m/s. Use uniform g = 9.8 N/kg and Ug = 0 at height 0. A dissipative brake acts; the enlarged Earth–body–brake system is isolated, with no other stores changing. A student says Earth–body mechanical energy must be constant because gravity is conservative, says any mechanical decrease destroys total energy, and equates net force work on the body with the change in K + Ug. Find final mechanical energy, thermal energy increase and net force work on the body. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Mechanical ledger: Initial U = 470.4 J and K = 12 J, so initial Emech = 482.4 J. Final U = 176.4 J and K = 192 J, so final Emech = 368.4 J.
Dissipation: Mechanical decrease = 114 J, balanced by thermal increase in the enlarged isolated system. Conservative gravity alone does not remove the brake’s dissipative interaction.
Work theorem: Wnet = ΔK = 192 − 12 = +180 J. Gravity does +294 J and the brake −114 J. The mechanical change is −114 J, not the net work.
☷ CHALLENGE — Classify the Mechanical-Energy Ledger
DOK 2 — ApplyClassify the Mechanical-Energy Ledger
Classify the mechanical energy of the system explicitly named in each card, over the stated interval. Only the listed transfers and interactions occur.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
A isolated system can conserve total energy while its mechanical energy decreases. An externally driven system can gain mechanical energy even without friction.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: Explain why a swing’s turning height decreases after pumping stops. Name the interacting system, distinguish mechanical energy from a larger total-energy ledger, explain the role of thermal energy, and state how active pumping changes the boundary transfers.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 4.4 — Mechanical Energy
Choose the system. Balance every energy change.
1. Define the selected mechanical energy
Emech = K + Ugravitational + Uelastic + …
Include potential energies only for the interactions or deformation represented within the selected system. Near Earth, choose Earth and body to include Ug = mg(y − yref). Choose block and spring to include Us = ½kx² for an ideal Hookean spring.
Our particle tasks use translational K = ½mv². A rolling wheel or ball may also have rotational kinetic energy. Do not apply a sliding-particle speed result to rolling motion without checking the model. The gravitational zero changes energy values, but not endpoint changes.
2. State the conditions for mechanical conservation
Kinitial + Uinitial = Kfinal + Ufinal
Use this when net external work is zero and no internal dissipative interaction converts mechanical energy to other stores. A fixed ideal normal support does zero work. No friction alone is insufficient: an external motor or moving support can transfer energy.
Total energy conservation is broader than mechanical conservation. Account for internal, thermal and other stores and transfers through the selected boundary. A isolated enlarged system can have a constant total while K + U decreases.
3. Ideal gravitational conversion
For a sliding particle starting from rest, with only gravity transferring between included mechanical stores:
mgΔh = ½mv²; v = √(2gΔh)
Use the vertical drop, take the square root and state the model. Mass cancels in this ideal result. With initial speed u, v² = u² + 2gΔh under the same conditions. At a turning point K may be zero, but the chosen gravitational U need not be zero.
4. Ideal spring conversion
On a smooth horizontal surface, an ideal massless spring can exchange elastic U and a block’s K. For release from rest at deformation x0, total energy is ½kx0². At the first undeformed crossing, spring U is zero and K is that total. Equal compression and extension magnitudes give equal initial elastic energy.
5. Keep the two brake ledgers separate
For the Earth–body mechanical system on the lab ramp, brake work is external:
Δ(K + Ug) = Wbrake = −Rs
Here R is sliding resistance magnitude and s is distance travelled down the ramp. Normal work is zero. For the enlarged isolated Earth–body–brake system, the same interaction is internal:
Δ(K + Ug) + ΔEthermal = 0; ΔEthermal = Rs
Use one consistent boundary and do not count the same brake loss both as external work and as an internal thermal increase. Real systems may need sound, deformation, air or other surroundings included too.
6. Net force work is a different change
Wnet on body = ΔK
On the ramp, gravity work is −ΔUg and brake work is −Rs. Their sum is ΔK. The change in K + Ug is brake work alone under the stated model. Counting gravity work again when it is already represented by the potential decrease double counts its energy transfer.
7. Early stopping and holding
While moving down a ramp at angle θ, the lab uses a = g sin θ − R/m. A sufficiently strong resistance can bring a moving body to rest before the foot. The lab ends at the exact first stop, retaining gravitational U at that height, and does not continue to negative K or uphill reversal.
If released at rest with mg sin θ ≤ R, the ideal brake supplies a balancing force within its holding capacity, so the body stays at rest and no work or thermal increase occurs. If mg sin θ exceeds R, downhill sliding starts. The chosen R is the magnitude while sliding, not a claim that the full R acts in every held-at-rest setup.
8. Read the energy graph
The graph plots K, Ug, Emech and the enlarged accounted sum Emech + thermal against distance down the ramp. Vertical values are energy in J. Graph area has units J·m and is not energy. For constant sliding resistance, the mechanical-energy slope is −R.
Only the traversed distance is traced. The ramp drawing is rescaled to each geometry; compare labelled distances and energies. A stronger brake can stop the particle before its starting gravitational energy is fully converted.
9. A loop needs a contact check
Energy alone does not ensure that an unrestrained sliding particle remains against the inside of a smooth circular loop. At its top, radial dynamics requires N = mv²/R − mg ≥ 0, so v² ≥ gR. In the ideal release-from-rest model, combining this with the top height 2R gives a minimum release height H = 2.5R above the bottom.
For H = 30 m and R = 10 m, energy gives top speed 14 m/s and the contact condition is satisfied. A positive speed alone would not establish that conclusion. A restrained car or a different track requires its own force model.
10. Explain a slowing swing
Once active pumping stops, air resistance and bearing interactions can convert mechanical energy into thermal energy and transfer energy to the surroundings. Include those surroundings in a larger ledger to conserve total energy. Active pumping supplies additional energy; turning heights do not then follow the passive ideal model.
AS 5.1–5.2 covers conservation, gravitational changes and kinetic energy; AS 6.2 includes elastic energy. AP Physics 1 3.4 treats selected systems, total and mechanical energy, transfers and conservation.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I choose a system and state its boundary.
- I include all relevant kinetic and potential stores.
- I state conditions before conserving mechanical energy.
- I account for thermal changes and external transfers.
- I distinguish net work ΔK from Δ(K + U).
- I check motion and contact limits beyond an energy equation.
— Crest ☆ “Choose the system. Balance every energy change.”
Mission 4.4 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Mechanical Energy
Mechanical energy can decrease, increase or stay constant. Total energy accounting depends on included stores and energy crossing the selected boundary.