WONDER — The Mystery
The Skateboard Throw
You and your skateboard initially rest while you hold a ball. You throw it along a smooth horizontal track. Why does your velocity change? If you were already moving before the throw, must your final ground velocity point backward?
Model: One-dimensional nonrelativistic recoil. Choose an inertial track frame and right positive. Include both separating bodies in the system; their combined mass stays fixed and external horizontal impulse is negligible. Zero total momentum is the special case of zero initial total momentum.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictSkater A has mass 100 kg and skater B has mass 50 kg. Both start at rest and push apart with negligible external horizontal impulse. Who has greater speed afterward?
Commit to both a prediction and a reason before revealing the explanation.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction and reasoning saved.
The total begins at zero and remains zero. Momentum magnitudes match, so the 50 kg skater has twice the speed of the 100 kg skater. The interaction forces are equal and opposite.
▶ PLAY — Recoil, Reference Frame and Moving Starts
DOK 2 — InvestigatePredict, measure and compare
Compare two ball-velocity inputs with the same masses, initial velocity and frame. Then change only skater mass from one of that pair. Measure three matched setups. Explore a moving start and switch the stated reference frame.
Select skater plus board and ball together. Skater mass excludes the ball. Both initially share the same ground velocity. Release occurs at 0.5 s and is idealized as an instantaneous internal impulse; afterward they coast until 2 s. Velocity input frame 0 = final ball velocity relative to the track; frame 1 = final ball velocity relative to the skater. Frame 1 is an AS/reference-frame extension. Point markers share one position scale; separate rows keep labels readable.
Status: Ready
Playback: 1 simulation seconds per real second. Pause or Step for measurements.
Momentum vs Time
Measurements
Load givens — then predict and run
Loading a setup earns no trial credit.
♢ DISCOVER — Conservation Before Shortcuts
DOK 1 — RecallFlip all 4 rule cards. Keep the quantities and model conditions clear.
Rule 1
Use the stated initial momentum
Click to flip
Use the stated initial momentum
Total final momentum equals total initial momentum when net external impulse is negligible. For two initially co-moving masses, initial total is (M + m)U. It is zero only when U = 0 in that frame.
Rule 2
Distinguish force, impulse and velocity
Click to flip
Distinguish force, impulse and velocity
The bodies exert equal and opposite interaction forces and receive equal and opposite internal impulses. Their velocity changes are inversely proportional to their masses. Final ground velocities need not be opposite for a moving system.
Rule 3
State the reference frame
Click to flip
State the reference frame
All momenta in one conservation equation use velocities in the same inertial frame. “Ball speed relative to the skater” is different from its track-frame velocity. The skater’s mass after release excludes the ball.
Rule 4
Account for energy
Click to flip
Account for energy
An internal spring, chemical store or muscular work can increase kinetic energy while total momentum stays constant. Momentum conservation alone does not imply kinetic-energy conservation. An explosion is not automatically a physical time reversal of a sticking collision.
All rules explored.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after an attempt; only a correct answer completes the claim.
Myth 1: “A cannon exerts a larger interaction force on the projectile than the projectile exerts on the cannon.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. Newton’s third law gives equal and opposite interaction forces. Different masses have different accelerations under those forces. External support forces must be assessed separately.
Myth 2: “Every explosion has zero total momentum afterward.”
Correct — the claim is false.
False. It preserves the initial total momentum only when net external impulse is negligible. A moving assembly usually has nonzero total momentum in the ground frame. An anchored launcher can receive external impulse.
Both myths corrected. Continue to the instructor questions.
✦ THE SECOND “AHA!” — Rest Is a Special Case
DOK 2 — ApplyState the frame, initial motion and selected system. “Recoil” describes a velocity change, not an automatic direction in every frame.
Instructor Q1 — Moving Assembly
An assembly is initially moving right, then separates with negligible external horizontal impulse. What is conserved?
Instructor Q2 — Energy Release
Two carts initially rest with a compressed spring between them. The spring pushes them apart on a frictionless track. Which statement is correct?
Instructor Q3 — Recoil Velocity
A 50 kg skater plus board, excluding a 2 kg ball, initially rests. After a throw the ball’s track-frame velocity is +6 m/s. External horizontal impulse is negligible. Find skater track-frame velocity.
Instructor Q4 — Moving Total
A 70 kg skater plus board holds a 4 kg ball. Both move right at 3 m/s. Find their initial total signed momentum.
4/4 — Instructor Questions Completed
Equal and opposite internal impulses conserve total momentum; a moving start need not give opposite final ground velocities.
✎ PRACTICE — Independent Recoil Cases
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: A Free Launcher
A launcher of mass 720 kg and a projectile of mass 6 kg initially rest on a smooth horizontal track. After firing, the projectile has track-frame velocity +84 m/s. The launcher’s stated mass excludes the projectile. External horizontal impulse is negligible. Find the signed launcher velocity and impulse delivered to the projectile.
Step-by-Step Solution
Initial total momentum is zero. Projectile momentum is +504 kg·m/s, so launcher momentum is −504 kg·m/s and its velocity is −504/720 = −0.70 m/s. The projectile gains impulse +504 N·s.
Challenge 2: Brief Gas Ejection
A vehicle and one gas packet initially have combined mass 650 kg and are at rest in an inertial frame. After a brief ejection, the remaining vehicle has mass 638 kg and the gas packet has mass 12 kg with velocity −180 m/s in that same frame. External impulse is negligible. Treat this as a single two-body event. Find vehicle velocity and the increase in total kinetic energy.
Step-by-Step Solution
Gas momentum = −2160 kg·m/s; vehicle momentum is +2160 kg·m/s, so v = 2160/638 ≈ 3.386 m/s.
Initial kinetic energy is zero. Final total is ½(638)v² + ½(12)(180²) ≈ 198056.426 J. This increase comes from the vehicle’s internal energy store; total energy is not created.
Challenge 3: Audit the Moving Throw
A 72 kg skater plus board holds a 3 kg ball; the 72 kg excludes the ball. Initially both move at +2 m/s in the track frame. After a throw, the ball’s track-frame velocity is +12 m/s. External horizontal impulse is negligible. A student reports: (i) initial total momentum is zero because this is a throw; (ii) final skater mass is 75 kg; (iii) total kinetic energy must stay unchanged because momentum is conserved. Calculate initial total momentum, final skater velocity and kinetic-energy increase. Explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Initial state: total momentum = (72 + 3) × 2 = +150 kg·m/s, not zero.
Final masses: ball momentum is 3 × 12 = +36 kg·m/s, so the 72 kg skater has +114 kg·m/s and velocity +1.5833 m/s. Its velocity has decreased by 0.4167 m/s but it still moves right.
Energy: initial kinetic energy is 150 J. Final kinetic energy is ½(72)(114/72)² + ½(3)(12²) = 306.25 J. Increase = 156.25 J, supplied by internal energy. Conserved total momentum does not require unchanged kinetic energy.
☷ CHALLENGE — Rocket in Space — Check the Claims
DOK 2 — ApplyRocket in Space — Check the Claims
A vehicle and gas start at rest in an inertial frame. A brief gas-ejection event leaves a 480 kg vehicle and a 20 kg gas packet. Gas velocity is −150 m/s in that original frame. External impulse is negligible. Judge each claim about this event; this is not a continuous-burn rocket-equation problem.
0 / 6 correct
Physics Insight
A rocket exchanges momentum with expelled gas. A brief fixed-total-mass separation can be analyzed without the continuous variable-mass rocket equation.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: A younger learner says a launcher can recoil only by pushing against air and that every throw must leave the thrower moving backward in the ground frame. Explain the interaction partner, external-impulse condition and effect of an initially moving system.
Use simple words and at least three short sentences. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a labelled explanation with at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare your physics with the Vault or your teacher.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
Crest’s Secret Notebook
Mission 3.19 — Explosions & Recoil
Recoil changes motion. Momentum keeps its balance.
1. Conservation first
Pfinal − Pinitial = Jexternal
For negligible external impulse, Pfinal = Pinitial. For two masses initially moving together at U, their initial total momentum is (M + m)U. Zero sum is the special case U = 0 in the chosen inertial frame.
2. The zero-sum special case
If both bodies start at rest and external impulse is negligible, MvS + mvB = 0. Their momentum vectors are equal and opposite. Different masses then have different speeds. Newton’s third law concerns forces; equal and opposite impulses produce inverse-mass velocity changes.
3. A momentum table with a moving start
| Object | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Skater + board | MU | MvS |
| Ball | mU | mvB |
| Total | (M + m)U | (M + m)U |
All velocities refer to the same inertial frame. After release, M excludes the ball. A decrease in skater velocity is recoil relative to the initial motion; a sufficiently large initial forward velocity can leave both bodies moving forward.
4. Ground or relative velocity?
If the ball’s final ground velocity vB is given, vS = [(M + m)U − mvB]/M.
If its final velocity relative to the skater is w, then vB − vS = w. Combining this relation with conservation gives vS = U − mw/(M + m) and vB = U + Mw/(M + m).
The relative-speed relation is a reference-frame/AS extension. AP Physics 1’s assessed quantitative treatment here is the one-dimensional ground-frame recoil case; it does not require a continuously changing-mass rocket calculation.
5. Energy is supplied internally
A spring, chemical store or muscular work can increase total kinetic energy while momentum is conserved. Energy is transferred from an internal store, not created. For a two-body separation from shared velocity U, kinetic-energy increase is ½[Mm/(M + m)](vB − vS)².
A reversed film of a sticking collision resembles separation kinematically. It is not automatically a physical time reversal: a sticking collision disperses kinetic energy, while separation needs an energy supply. Momentum accounting works in both, with the actual initial state and external impulse.
6. Rockets and system boundaries
A rocket interacts with expelled gas and does not need air. Include vehicle plus the specified gas packet for a brief separation event. Specify remaining vehicle mass and gas velocity’s frame. If the launcher is anchored, its support can supply external impulse; launcher-plus-projectile momentum is then not automatically constant.
A continuous burn involves changing vehicle mass and exhaust released at different times. It needs additional modeling and is outside this mission’s finite two-body calculations.
7. Use the lab
Before 0.5 s the skater and ball share U. Release is modeled as an instantaneous internal impulse at 0.5 s; afterward the point bodies coast until 2 s. The graph shows the individual momentum jumps and unchanged total using only elapsed data. No finite contact-force curve is calculated.
The position markers use separate rows but one x scale, with a center-of-mass marker. The center of mass continues at U throughout. At a moving start, compare momentum changes as well as final momenta: internal changes cancel even when final momenta are not equal and opposite.
Frame 0 supplies a track-frame ball velocity; frame 1 supplies ball velocity relative to the skater. Example: from rest, a 50 kg skater and 5 kg ball with relative separation velocity +6 m/s have skater velocity −0.545 m/s and ball velocity +5.455 m/s in the track frame. A track-frame input of +6 m/s would give a different recoil.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I state the inertial reference frame and positive direction.
- I include both bodies in the chosen system.
- I check external impulse rather than assuming isolation.
- I set total momentum to zero only when the initial total is zero.
- I use remaining mass and distinguish relative from ground velocity.
- I explain the source of any kinetic-energy increase.
— Crest ☆ “Recoil changes motion. Momentum keeps its balance.”
Mission 3.19 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
★ Master of Explosions & Recoil
Equal and opposite internal impulses conserve total momentum; a moving start need not give opposite final ground velocities.