WONDER — The Mystery
Three Graphs, One Ball
A ball moves up, slows, turns and falls. The same motion looks curved on a position graph, straight on a velocity graph and flat on an acceleration graph. How can all three pictures be correct?
Model: one-dimensional motion, upward positive, x measured from a fixed origin. The diagrams use illustrative constant acceleration −4 m/s², not Earth’s gravity. A real free-flight toss near Earth has a ≈ −9.8 m/s² if air resistance is negligible; launch and catch are outside that free-flight model.
Today’s Mission: read instantaneous velocity and acceleration from gradients; read displacement and velocity change from signed areas. Recover final values using starting values, and distinguish a stop, a turn and an origin crossing.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictA straight velocity–time line falls from (0 s, +12 m/s) to (4 s, +4 m/s). Right is positive. What does the corresponding position–time trace do during this interval?
Choose the position–time behavior over the same interval.
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction: B) It rises with decreasing steepness.
Velocity stays positive, so position rises. Velocity becomes smaller, so its positive position gradient becomes less steep. The correct WHY uses both the sign and the changing size of velocity. The v–t gradient is (4 − 12)/4 = −2 m/s²; negative acceleration here reduces a positive velocity.
The vertical position offset cannot be determined without a starting position. Different x–t curves can have the same velocity trace.
▶ PLAY — Motion Graph Trio Lab
DOK 2 — InvestigateWhat you will DO and OBSERVE
- • DO: set a starting position, two velocity values and a duration, or set acceleration instead of the final velocity. Complete a non-zero run.
- • OBSERVE: one time marker moves through all three graphs. Watch the tangent and both signed areas.
- • DISCOVER: compare crossing the origin with stopping, and zero velocity with zero acceleration.
Right is positive; x is a coordinate from a fixed origin. Each run has constant acceleration. Choose the given quantities; calculated controls are disabled and labelled. Playback is accelerated; t is physical time. Switching modes resets the run.
Reading the diagram: cyan is position, green velocity, gold acceleration. Grey dashes show the plan. White dashes on x–t are the current tangent. Pale green and red areas on v–t mark positive and negative displacement; the a–t area gives velocity change. The lower track uses a fixed metre scale for this run; gold marks the origin.
Status: Ready
Live Readouts
Try these experiments
Choose a preset, predict the trio, then press Play. Presets do not start playback.
DISCOVER — The Golden Rules
DOK 1 — RecallYou've played with the Trio Lab. Now flip each card to reveal the four golden rules of motion-graph analysis.
Rule #1
The Graph Chain
Click to flip
Gradients give rates
Instantaneous velocity is the tangent gradient of x–t. Instantaneous acceleration is the tangent gradient of v–t. A straight segment has a constant gradient. Read the axes and their units first.
Rule #2
Area Integration
Click to flip
Areas give changes
Signed a–t area gives Δv; add the initial velocity to get the final velocity. Signed v–t area gives Δx; add the initial position to get the final position. Below the time axis contributes negatively.
Rule #3
Turning Points & Intercepts
Click to flip
Stops and turns
At a smooth x–t peak or valley, v = 0. A turn requires a velocity sign change. Merely touching v = 0 need not mean a turn. Crossing x = 0 reaches the fixed origin, which need not be the start.
Rule #4
Speed and Acceleration
Click to flip
Speed and acceleration
Speed is |v|. When v and a have the same sign, speed increases; opposite signs make speed decrease. At a turn, v can be zero while a is non-zero. A constant negative acceleration can eventually increase speed.
Memory: gradients give instantaneous rates; signed areas give changes. Add starting values to recover final values.
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzePick TRUE or FALSE for each myth. A wrong answer gives feedback and a retry; only a correct answer counts as completion.
Myth #1: “Whenever velocity is zero, acceleration must also be zero.”
Correct — the claim is false.
At t = 3 s the velocity is zero, but the v–t line still has gradient (−9 − 9)/6 = −3 m/s². The object changes direction. Velocity describes current motion; acceleration describes its rate of change.
Myth #2: “Signed area under a velocity–time graph always equals total distance travelled.”
Correct — the claim is false.
Signed area gives displacement. Positive and negative contributions can cancel. Distance adds their magnitudes; split at any velocity sign change. Here displacement is zero but distance is 4.5 m.
Both claims corrected. Keep velocity, acceleration, displacement and distance distinct.
THE SECOND 'AHA!' — Instructor Drill
DOK 2 — ApplyAnswer four graph questions. Each figure supplies the data; get all four right to unlock practice. Guides appear after an attempt.
Live Graph for Current Question
Current Question Scenario
Waiting for Q1...
Instructor Q1 — Gradient of a Flat Velocity Line
The straight velocity–time segment is horizontal below zero. What is its acceleration?
Instructor Q2 — Area of an Acceleration Record
What does the signed area of this acceleration–time record give over 0–4 s?
Instructor Q3 — Compute Signed Acceleration
A straight velocity–time segment joins (1 s, +12 m/s) and (5 s, −4 m/s). Find the signed acceleration in m/s².
Instructor Q4 — Compute Displacement
A straight velocity–time segment joins (0 s, +10 m/s) and (5 s, 0 m/s). Find the displacement over 0–5 s in metres.
4/4 — Graphs Mastered!
You connected gradients, signed areas and the quantities they represent. Time to practice!
✎ PRACTICE — Audit the Graph Chain
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: Read the Velocity Record
A straight velocity–time segment joins (2 s, +14 m/s) and (8 s, +2 m/s). Right is positive. Find the signed acceleration in m/s².
Step-by-Step Solution
Identify: acceleration is the velocity–time gradient.
Substitute: a = (2 − 14)/(8 − 2) = −12/6.
Solve: a = −2 m/s². Positive velocity becomes smaller.
Challenge 2: Recover the Final Velocity
At t = 1 s an object has velocity −2 m/s. Its acceleration is +4 m/s² from 1 to 3 s, zero from 3 to 5 s, and −1 m/s² from 5 to 8 s. Right is positive. Find its velocity at 8 s in m/s.
Step-by-Step Solution
Read signed areas: Δv₁ = 4(3 − 1) = +8 m/s; Δv₂ = 0; Δv₃ = −1(8 − 5) = −3 m/s.
Combine: Δv = 8 + 0 − 3 = +5 m/s.
Add the starting value: v(8 s) = −2 + 5 = +3 m/s, rightward. The +5 m/s area is the change, not the final velocity.
Challenge 3: Audit the Motion Report
A straight velocity–time line joins (0 s, +6 m/s) and (6 s, −6 m/s). Right is positive; the initial position is +4 m relative to a fixed origin. A student writes: “At 3 s the object is at rest, so its acceleration is zero. The two signed areas cancel, so both its total distance and final position are zero.” Find the total distance and final position at 6 s, then explain all three errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Correct acceleration: a = (−6 − 6)/6 = −2 m/s² throughout. At 3 s, v = 0 while its gradient remains −2 m/s²; the object turns.
Correct distance: positive area = ½(3)(6) = +9 m; negative area = −9 m. Distance = |9| + |−9| = 18 m. Signed displacement is zero.
Correct position: final position = +4 + 0 = +4 m. Returning to the starting coordinate does not mean reaching the fixed origin. The peak position is +13 m.
Explanation marking uses an indicative text rubric, not a complete semantic assessment. Compare your submitted reasoning with the worked solution or a teacher.
☷ CHALLENGE — Rebuild the Graph Chain
DOK 2 — ApplyFrom Acceleration to Final Position
The a–t record shows +2 m/s² from 0 to 4 s. The object starts with v₀ = −3 m/s at x₀ = +2 m. Right is positive. Arrange six linked steps that recover the velocity graph and final position. Select a card, then a slot; select a filled slot to return it.
Build the solution in order:
Available steps (shuffled — pick one, then click a slot):
Physics Insight — Why Starting Values Matter
A flat a–t record fixes the change in velocity, but different initial velocities give different v–t lines. Each velocity line fixes displacement, but different starting positions shift its x–t curve. A change alone cannot recover an absolute value.
Taking gradients is differentiation; accumulating signed areas is integration. Calculus is useful language for this connection. Numerical tasks here use constant or piecewise-constant acceleration, with triangles and rectangles for area.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: your younger sibling sees three different motion graphs for one ball. Explain how gradients and signed areas connect them, and why the starting values matter.
Teach why a ball can have zero velocity while its acceleration remains non-zero. Type at least three short sentences, or draw a labelled explanation using at least three purposeful strokes. Exact keywords are not required.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw and label the x–t, v–t and a–t graphs for a turning object. Connect one instant across all three; add at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare the physics with the Vault.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — Crest's private notebook.
📓 Crest’s Secret Notebook
📊Mission 2.13 — Motion Graph Analysis
Three graphs, one motion.
x–t tangent gradient = instantaneous velocity v.
v–t tangent gradient = instantaneous acceleration a.
Signed a–t area = Δv; v_final = v_initial + Δv.
Signed v–t area = Δx; x_final = x_initial + Δx.
Constant a: v = v₀ + at; x = x₀ + v₀t + ½at².
Distance = sum of magnitudes of v–t areas between velocity sign changes.
1. Read the axes first
A graph’s height is its vertical quantity. Its gradient is a rate of change. Its area combines the two axis units. Use the tangent for an instant and a secant for an interval average.
| Graph | Gradient | Signed area |
|---|---|---|
| Position–time | Velocity / m/s | Unit m·s; it does not give velocity |
| Velocity–time | Acceleration / m/s² | Displacement / m |
| Acceleration–time | Rate of change of acceleration; optional enrichment | Velocity change / m/s |
2. A signed area is a change
Area below the time axis is negative. Combine signed contributions for displacement or velocity change. Then add the appropriate initial value. A v–t graph alone cannot give the position coordinate without an initial position.
For a straight v–t segment, signed displacement = ½(v_initial + v_final) × duration. If it crosses zero, positive and negative areas can cancel. For distance, split at the sign change and add area magnitudes.
3. Zero does not mean everything stops changing
At a smooth local peak or valley on x–t, its tangent is horizontal and v = 0. A turn requires a change in the sign of velocity. A velocity trace can touch zero and continue with the same sign. At a sharp graph corner, there may be no single tangent; compare the adjacent segments.
A non-zero acceleration can act when v = 0, as at the top of a free-flight toss. On x–t, x = 0 means reaching a fixed origin. Returning to the start means x equals its initial coordinate; these are the same only if the start was the origin.
4. Shapes and signs tell different parts of the story
- A straight x–t segment has constant velocity and zero acceleration.
- A parabolic x–t trace is the constant non-zero acceleration case. Include x₀ in its equation.
- A straight sloping v–t segment has constant non-zero acceleration; a horizontal v–t segment has zero acceleration.
- A curved v–t trace has changing acceleration. Qualitative curvature does not require a numerical calculus calculation here.
- When v and a have the same sign, speed increases; opposite signs make speed decrease. At v = 0, inspect the motion on both sides.
5. Two objects: meeting or matching?
On a common position axis and clock, x–t intersections mean equal position at the same time. v–t intersections mean equal velocity, which alone does not establish a meeting. Equal accelerations alone also say nothing about equal positions.
🚨 Crest’s Exam Secrets
Height versus gradient
A v–t value of zero says “instantaneously at rest.” A v–t gradient of zero says “zero acceleration.” Read the requested quantity before choosing an operation.
Signed change versus travel
A zero signed v–t area can describe a return after substantial travel. Distance is non-negative and at least the magnitude of net displacement.
Start and finish matter
Use the recorded interval, even if its first time is not zero. Δt = final time − initial time. Area under a–t gives Δv, not v_final; area under v–t gives Δx, not x_final.
Earth toss model
Upward positive, negligible air resistance, near Earth: a ≈ −9.8 m/s² throughout free flight. v changes sign at the top; acceleration remains downward. Launch and catch introduce other forces.
🧠 Memory hooks
- Gradient: how fast the vertical quantity changes.
- Signed area: how much the next quantity changes.
- Change + starting value = final value.
- Zero velocity needs a sign change to identify a turn.
✨ Bonus wonder — invisible offsets
Add 100 m to every position coordinate. The x–t curve shifts upward but its gradients, velocity, acceleration, displacement and distance stay unchanged. A velocity graph cannot reveal that shift. This is why starting position information matters.
Optional enrichment: the rate of change of acceleration is called jerk, with unit m/s³. It is outside the numerical core of this mission.
✓ Crest’s Checklist
- I read the axes, units, direction and interval.
- I distinguish graph height, tangent gradient and signed area.
- I add starting values to recover final values.
- I split distance calculations at velocity sign changes.
- I check whether zero velocity is a turn or merely a touch.
- I distinguish equal position from equal velocity.
— Crest ✨ “Connect the graphs. Keep the starting values.”
Mission 2.13 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
🏅 Master of Motion Graph Analysis
Slope UP, Area DOWN — three graphs, one calculus chain, fully mastered.