WONDER — The Mystery
Two Graphs, One Journey
A runner jogs 10 m east, stops for a moment, then jogs 5 m west back toward the start.
Graph conventions: cumulative distance D starts at zero for this journey. A position coordinate x is measured from a fixed origin; it can start above or below zero. Displacement over a recorded interval is the change in x. Here the origin is the runner’s starting point, and east is positive. Straight sections model constant velocity; turns are idealised.
If you plot the journey on a DISTANCE-TIME graph, the line never slopes downward — cumulative distance is non-decreasing, because you can't "un-walk" a path. Even walking back adds to the total distance.
But on a DISPLACEMENT-TIME graph, the line goes UP (moving east), flattens (stopped), then goes DOWN (moving west — displacement is decreasing as you return toward the start).
The Mystery:
It's the same trip, same runner, same stopwatch. Yet the two graphs tell different stories — the distance graph never slopes downward, while the displacement graph can rise or fall. How can a single journey produce two such different shapes?
Today’s Mission: distinguish cumulative distance, position and displacement. Read speed or signed velocity from the relevant gradient, find travel across reversals, and separate crossing an origin from returning to a starting position.
PREDICT — Commit to Your Answer
DOK 2 — PredictScenario: A car drives 20 m east, stops, then drives 10 m west back toward the start.
What will the DISTANCE-TIME graph look like?
Step 1: Pick your answer.
STOP! Before revealing — why did you pick that?
Correct prediction: B) Rise, flatten, then rise again.
The useful WHY is “Count motion along both legs regardless of direction.” Cumulative distance rises while moving in either direction and is flat during the stop. This trip covers 20 + 10 = 30 m. Taking east as positive, displacement is 20 − 10 = +10 m.
With the start chosen as x = 0, the position graph rises on the eastward leg, is flat at the stop, and falls on the westward leg. Position is signed; accumulated path length never decreases.
▶ PLAY — The Two-Graph Journey Lab
DOK 2 — InvestigateWhat you will DO and OBSERVE
- • DO: set signed leg changes or leg velocities, both travel times and a pause. Complete a non-zero journey using Play or Step.
- • OBSERVE: cumulative distance rises in either direction; displacement follows the signed motion. Both graphs flatten during a pause.
- • DISCOVER: compare returns, origin crossings and journeys in one direction. Compare speed with signed velocity.
East is positive. Both graphs start at zero for this journey; displacement is measured from the starting point. Each leg has constant velocity, with idealised abrupt changes at the joins. Choose which quantities are given. Calculated controls are disabled and labelled. Playback is accelerated; t is physical elapsed time.
Reading the diagram: both horizontal axes show time. Green is cumulative distance; amber is signed displacement from the start. Grey dashes show the whole plan. The lower track shows the runner on a fixed metre scale for this run; the gold mark is the start.
Status: Ready
Live Readouts
Try these experiments
Choose a preset, predict both graph shapes, then press Play. Presets do not start playback.
DISCOVER — The Golden Rules
DOK 1 — RecallYou've played with the Graph Lab. Now flip each card to reveal the four golden rules for mastering distance-time vs displacement-time graphs.
Rule #1
Distance-Time Graphs
Click to flip
Cumulative distance
D is total path length travelled since the journey began. It never decreases: it rises during motion and stays flat during rest. A straight distance–time gradient gives speed, which is non-negative. Travel within a recorded interval is D₂ − D₁.
Rule #2
Displacement-Time Graphs
Click to flip
Signed position and velocity
A straight position–time gradient gives signed velocity. East-positive: rising x means eastward motion, falling x means westward motion. Graph height is position, not speed. A constant falling gradient means constant westward speed. A flat segment means rest.
Rule #3
Total Distance vs Net Displacement
Click to flip
Travel versus change of position
Net displacement = final position − initial position. Add magnitudes of position changes between direction reversals for distance; a pause adds zero. The final coordinate alone is displacement only if the initial coordinate is zero.
Rule #4
Key Comparison
Click to flip
Origin or starting point?
Crossing x = 0 means reaching the chosen origin. Returning to the start means x equals the initial coordinate; these coincide only if the start is the origin. Distance ≥ |net displacement|. Equality holds for straight motion without reversal, including rests.
All four rules unlocked!
MISCONCEPTION ATTACK — Destroy the Myths
DOK 2 — AnalyzeChoose TRUE or FALSE for each claim. The explanation appears after your attempt.
💀 Myth #1: "Distance-time and displacement-time graphs are always the same."
Correct — the claim is false.
With cumulative distance starting at zero, the two graphs match numerically only while motion is in the chosen positive direction. Returning adds more path length but reverses the position gradient. Motion solely in the negative direction gives D = |Δx|, while the signed displacement graph lies below zero.
💀 Myth #2: "A distance-time graph can go down when you walk back."
Correct — the claim is false.
Cumulative distance never decreases. A return leg still adds path length. A falling position graph means motion in the negative direction; it does not reduce the path already travelled.
Myths destroyed! You're inoculated against the two biggest distance/displacement graph traps.
THE SECOND 'AHA!' — Instructor Drill
DOK 2 — ApplyAnswer four graph questions. Each figure supplies the data; the tiles record correct responses. Get all four right to unlock practice.
Live Graph for Current Question
Current Question Scenario
Waiting for Q1...
Instructor Q1 — Distance-Time Shape
During 2–6 s, what is the object doing on this cumulative distance–time record?
Instructor Q2 — Displacement-Time Shape
The position–time line is straight and falls across x = 0. East is positive. What does its gradient tell you?
Instructor Q3 — Compute Total Distance
The straight position–time segment joins (2 s, +12 m) and (6 s, 0 m). East is positive. Find the signed velocity in m/s.
Instructor Q4 — Compute Net Displacement
The position–time record joins (0 s, 0 m), (3 s, +9 m) and (7 s, −3 m) with straight segments. Find the total distance from 0 to 7 s in m.
4/4 — Graphs Mastered!
You now know: distance-time never slopes downward, displacement-time can fall, distance = sum of segments, displacement = final − initial. Time to practice!
✎ PRACTICE — Two Graphs, One Journey
DOK 1–3 — PracticeChallenge 1: The Straight Track
A straight position–time segment joins (0 s, 0 m) and (6 s, +24 m). East is positive. Find the signed velocity in m/s.
Step-by-Step Solution
Identify: a straight position–time gradient gives velocity.
Substitute: v = (24 − 0)/(6 − 0) = 24/6.
Solve: v = +4 m/s, eastward.
Challenge 2: The Converted Journey
Time is in minutes and position is in kilometres relative to a fixed origin. East is positive. The straight-segment record joins (1 min, +0.40 km), (3 min, −0.20 km), (4 min, −0.20 km) and (6 min, +0.10 km). Find the total distance travelled from 1 to 6 min, in metres.
Step-by-Step Solution
Read the legs: Δx₁ = −0.20 − 0.40 = −0.60 km; the stop adds 0; Δx₂ = 0.10 − (−0.20) = +0.30 km.
Add travel: distance = |−0.60| + 0 + |+0.30| = 0.90 km.
Convert: 0.90 × 1000 = 900 m. The negative first leg is travel in the negative direction, not negative distance.
Challenge 3: Audit the Origin Report
The position–time trace joins (0 s, +6 m), (2 s, +18 m), (3 s, +18 m) and (7 s, −6 m) with straight segments. Positions are relative to a fixed origin; east is positive. A student reports: “At 6 s, x = 0, so the object has returned to its starting position. The final value −6 m is the distance travelled.” Find the total distance and net displacement from 0 to 7 s, then explain both errors.
Step-by-Step Solution
Correct the values: position changes are +12 m, 0 m and −24 m. Distance = 12 + 0 + 24 = 36 m. Net displacement = −6 − (+6) = −12 m, westward.
Audit the crossing: x = 0 at 6 s means reaching the fixed origin. The object started at x = +6 m and passed that starting position at 5 s. The origin crossing is not a return to the start.
Audit the endpoint: −6 m is the final signed position coordinate. Distance is accumulated path length and cannot be negative. It is neither the final coordinate nor the net displacement.
☷ CHALLENGE — The Journey Sequence
DOK 2 — ApplySequence the Position Record
The position–time trace joins (0 s, −5 m), (3 s, +10 m), (5 s, +10 m) and (8 s, −8 m). East is positive. Arrange six linked steps to find the net displacement and total distance. Select a card, then a slot; select a filled slot to return it.
Build the solution in order:
Available steps (shuffled — pick one, then click a slot):
Physics Insight — A Clock, a Coordinate and a Path
Position depends on a chosen origin. Displacement is a change between two positions. Distance records the path between them. Changing the origin shifts every position value by the same constant but changes neither displacement nor distance.
A cumulative distance graph cannot recover direction by itself. Use a signed position or velocity record to locate the object. A straight segment gives a constant gradient; a sharp corner has no single instantaneous gradient at the join.
TEACH — The Feynman Technique
DOK 3 — TeachYour Final Mission: your 10-year-old sibling sees two smartwatch graphs for the same trip. Explain why cumulative distance never falls while a position trace can rise or fall.
Explain what each gradient means and why crossing an origin may differ from returning to a starting position. Type at least three short sentences, or draw a labelled explanation using at least three purposeful strokes. Exact keywords are not required.
Type Your Explanation (≥ 3 sentences)
Draw a position–time trace and a cumulative distance–time trace for the same trip. Label axes and direction. Add at least three purposeful strokes. This checks effort; compare the physics with the Vault.
Cyan pen selected.
Final reward below
Hidden exam secrets inside — PHYSICS CREST mastery notebook.
📓 PHYSICS CREST Secret Notebook
📊Mission 2.12 — Mastering Distance-Time vs Displacement-Time Graphs
"The Runner's Two Graphs" 🚶📊
Net displacement: Δx = x_final − x_initial.
Distance: add |Δx| for every monotonic leg between direction reversals. A pause adds zero.
Straight position–time gradient: v = Δx/Δt. Straight cumulative distance–time gradient: speed = ΔD/Δt.
Average velocity = net displacement / elapsed time. Average speed = total distance / elapsed time.
🌍 OVERVIEW: Two Graphs, One Journey
One journey can be represented by cumulative distance or signed position. These graphs carry different information and need not have different shapes.
1. Distance-Time Graphs (SCALAR)
- Y-axis: Total path length traveled so far (always ≥ 0).
- Shape: NON-DECREASING — rises while moving and is horizontal while stopped; never slopes down.
- Slope: a straight distance–time gradient gives speed. A steeper gradient means greater speed on the same axis scales. A flat segment means rest.
- Reading distance: Just read the y-value at any time — that's the total path so far.
2. Displacement-Time Graphs (VECTOR)
- Y-axis: Displacement from the starting position (can be +, 0, or − when a positive direction is chosen).
- Shape: Can INCREASE for motion in the chosen positive direction or DECREASE for motion in the negative direction. It can go below zero after crossing the chosen origin.
- Slope: = signed VELOCITY. Positive slope = motion in the chosen positive direction; negative slope = motion in the negative direction; flat = stopped. Whether that is toward or away from the start depends on which side of the origin the object is on.
- Zero crossing: on a graph of displacement from the journey’s start, zero means return to that start. On a fixed-origin position graph, x = 0 means reaching the origin, which need not be the starting position.
3. Extracting Distance vs Displacement
From a displacement-time graph (the trickier one):
- Total Distance: Split the one-dimensional displacement graph into monotonic legs (between stops/turning points) and add the magnitude of each displacement change.
- Net displacement: final coordinate − initial coordinate, with sign. Use the final value alone only when the initial value is zero.
- From a distance-time graph: Distance = read y-axis directly. Displacement = CANNOT be determined from this graph alone (need direction info).
4. Key Comparison Table
| Feature | Distance-Time | Displacement-Time |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity | SCALAR | VECTOR |
| Y-axis | Cumulative path length | Displacement from starting position |
| Can decrease? | NO — never | YES — for motion in the negative direction |
| Slope = | Speed | Velocity (signed) |
| Round trip ends at | Twice one-way distance for a simple two-leg return | 0 (back at start) |
| Flat segment = | Stopped | Stopped |
5. When Are They Equal?
Distance = |Displacement| ONLY for straight-line, one-direction motion (no turning back).
- Walk 20 m east, stop → Distance = 20, Displacement = +20. Equal!
- Walk 20 m east, then 5 m west → Distance = 25, Displacement = +15. NOT equal.
- Round trip 20 m east then 20 m west → Distance = 40, Displacement = 0. NOT equal.
Golden Rule: Distance ≥ |Displacement| ALWAYS — with equality only for one-direction straight-line motion.
6. Simple Two-Leg Round Trip
- For a simple outward-and-return journey, distance: = 2 × one-way distance (both legs count).
- Displacement: = 0 (back at start).
- For a simple round trip starting in the positive direction, cumulative distance rises on both travel legs and is flat during stops.
- For a simple round trip starting in the positive direction, displacement rises, then returns to zero. Starting in the negative direction reverses this shape.
🚨 THE "CREST" EXAM SECRETS
🔑 EXAM TRAP #1: The "Same Graph" Myth
Students assume distance-time and displacement-time graphs look identical.
- The Trap: For motion with any reversal, the graphs look completely different!
- The Fix: Always check the y-axis label FIRST. "Distance" → scalar, non-decreasing (flat when stopped). "Displacement" → vector, can rise/fall.
⚠️ EXAM TRAP #2: The "Distance Goes Down" Myth
Students see a graph going down and call it "decreasing distance."
- WRONG! Distance can NEVER decrease. A downward-sloping segment cannot represent cumulative distance–time. Check the y-axis label before deciding what the graph means.
- The Fix: If a graph slopes downward, the vertical quantity is decreasing. That can occur on displacement/position, speed, velocity, or other graphs depending on the axis label — but not on a cumulative distance–time graph.
🧠 MEMORY TRICKS
- "D = Odometer" — A car's odometer never runs backward. A distance–time graph likewise never slopes downward.
- "Δx = signed displacement" — it can be positive, zero, or negative depending on which side of the chosen start the object is on.
- “Simple two-leg round trip: distance = twice the one-way distance; displacement = zero.” Extra detours can increase the distance further.
- "Slope tells the story" — distance–time slope = speed; displacement–time slope = signed velocity. Both are flat when the object is stopped.
📊 BONUS: How Real GPS Uses Both
A GPS trace can be used to calculate both distance (total path length) and displacement from a chosen starting point. Cumulative distance never decreases; signed displacement can increase, decrease, cross zero, or become negative. Distance remaining to a destination is a separate path-planning quantity, not displacement.
✨ Bonus wonder — move the origin
If a different origin adds 100 m to every position coordinate, all position differences and gradients stay the same. The distance and net displacement of the journey are unchanged, even though a crossing of x = 0 may disappear from the record.
✅ PHYSICS CREST CHECKLIST (memorize!)
- Distance-time graph: NON-DECREASING. Slope = speed. y = cumulative path length.
- Displacement-time graph: Can increase OR decrease. Slope = signed velocity. y = displacement from the starting position.
- Distance NEVER goes down — even when returning.
- From x-t graph: distance = sum of |up| + |down|; displacement = final − initial.
- Distance ≥ |Displacement|, with equality ONLY for one-direction straight-line motion.
- Simple two-leg round trip: distance = 2× one-way, displacement = 0.
- Always check y-axis label before interpreting any motion graph!
— PHYSICS CREST ✨
"Distance = Odometer (only up). Displacement = Position (up or down)."
Mission 2.12 Complete! · All 10 levels cleared · PHYSICS CREST
🏅 Master of Distance and Displacement Graphs
Distance-Time vs Displacement-Time Graphs — mastered. Same journey, two stories — and you can read them both!